Do you really think it is ? People do say, but these students are trying to make Pakistan like Taliban. I mean according to me Musharraf has nothing to do with it. He has just ordered the attack on the Mosque, which is Great !
5072007
khan(20:08:43) :
As the drama of lal masjid is on its peak, the reluctance of Pakistan army and other para malitary forces to launch a full fledge operation in Lal Masjid, I doubt that there might some high figures from AQ may be hidden in this mosque, as Maulana abdul aziz was having some direct links to these people.
Who is hidden inside?? except for the Gazi Rasheed and his body gaurds?????
6072007
SHAZIA A(00:30:00) :
All these militants deserve a military action like this sooner than later. I am glad Musharraf decided to do this. All these extremist fanatics who think they are bigger than the law deserve this. I hope our media does not paint a romantic /filmi pic of women militants just ‘cuz they are women.. thay all deserve this. It needs to send a message to any Mullah doing terrorism in name of Islam!!
And for those skeptics out their.. appreciate what Musharraf is trying to do…we need this or get ready for Pakistan to become another Afghanistan
just I want to say they are not Muslim it is tourism by the name of Islam I want to say one word it is that if I was president of Pakistan I was to cut maulana aziz and Abdul Rashid hade I mean I would kill them if I was president I am wait president parwez Musharaf Saab he is the great man in the pakistan even world God bless him inshalah even you can publish my words with all I am not afraid no one Except Allah just finish the tourisms Great Musharaf Pakistan Zenda Bad
6072007
Mahmood(01:56:16) :
It’s about time that the government closed down the Lal Masjid and similar centres which give a bad name to both Islam and Pakistan. I am disgusted that the Musharraf government waited so long to act. From the beginning they could have created a cordon around the Mosque to isolate and starve the group until they came to their senses. I believe that the Lal Masjid drama was kept alive by Musharraf for a while because it serves his interests. That is to say he wants to show the world that if not for the dictatorship of Musharraf, Pakistan would head towards Taliban style anarchy. This is simply untrue because most Pakistanis are fed up with these silly extremists who are taking the law into their own hands. The problem is that the current President also took the law into his own hands when he dismissed the civilian Prime Minister and made himself President and Chief. Musharraf too has no authority and perhaps that’s why there is so much lawlessness throughout the country. Monkey see and monkey do. If the army chief can break the consitution and flout laws why shouldn’t everyone else. We need rule of law for all which is why I would vote for the suspended Chief Justice if he ever runs for office!
6072007
IRFAN(02:46:45) :
I am in doubt that we are really muslims? To get some benefit in form of Aids from foreign countries, we are ready to kill each other. What is all behind this issue is just politics. And they are killing the innocent peoples. I have a question to pakistan government and other people involved in this operation that they are hitting mosque ( the Home of Allah). It is shame for all of us (muslims).
Pakistan politics are controlled by army generals, they are all sold out to America, So they can kill every Innocent Muslim in pakistan by declaring as AQ terriest, if they killing Innocent Muslim in Pakistan, one day a big Earth Quake will be destroyed the Islambad, and other area’s where, these army General living and enjoy there life and killing the innocent people in pakistan and got Money from America and Briton. One day Allah will Kepture from there head and dropped on floor. Allah helps the innocent Muslim os Pakistan and the rest of world. and save them from Army General who are big Terroriest in this world
6072007
KKK(19:20:09) :
This is a fight between understanding ISLAM. (Religion). Army generals and other modern MUSLIMS are influenced by Europeans culture and they studied all their life only secularism and know nothing about ISLAM. May ALLAH swt help all of us to understand ISLAM and practice it. INSHAHALLAH a day will come when truth separates from the lie. Be a slave of ALLAH, save your world and hereafter.
[...] This Pakistani blog is interesting in its own right if you like to get the perspective of people who actually live in an area. But I was particularly interested in the comments on this post here. [...]
7072007
khan(09:57:19) :
yaa kaam musharaf gandu ni aacha nahe keya ha
7072007
Mateen(11:41:15) :
sirf itna clear hona chaiye k ager islam ko phailana hay to piyar mohabat say phailao or ager sheriat ka nifaz kerna hay to sheriat main koi piyar mohabat or nermi nai hay. or Lal Masjid walay sheriat ka nifaz chahtay thay..woh bilkul theek thay theek hain or ham log ghalat hain jo unhain ghalat keh rahay hain..asal main ham log khud to kuch ker nai saktay or jo kernay lagay usay bura bhala kehtay hain..
7072007
muhammad iqbal(13:41:10) :
hi friends
it is a great plot being played against pakistan and the people of Pakistan. Who are mulvies, i think musharaf can better answer this question. In short army and molvies are doing nothing but facilitating the ways to handover pakistan completely to America.
isn’t it.
7072007
Ashraf Siddiqui(21:49:05) :
The actions taken by Lal Masjid and adjacent school organisors like picking up of Chinese prostitutes, burning of Video casettes or any other similar adventures are highly condemned. In the presence of country’s laws and concerned authorities, no one can atke the law in the hands.
Having said that, the present level of issue seems as if intentially created by General Pervez Musharaf and his team. He is trying to support his utmost to the disgraced extremists group leaders – the US President Bush and ousted UK Prime Minister Tony Blair. Both Western leaders have lost their support in their own people. I can’t understand that why still Pervez Musharaf is still batting on the lost horse. And not only that but also puting his own country on very dangerous stage and whole nation in continous torture.
Where was the govt writ before today. Why the parents of the children in mosque are not allowed to vist their children and get them back. Why today members of parliament were arrested today ? Why the parliamentarians when allowed to visit today the mosque, heavy fire started by the govt. forces ? Why until now those children who many days before left the mosque are now still in jail ? Why electricity, gas, water are disconnected for the residents of the area in miles and miles. Because the govt has fear that public will supor them ? How the heavy fire is open on the innocent children in mosque ? Who will give the answers to that. Shame on the present rulers
7072007
Mahmood(22:18:55) :
To me Pakistan means so much more than any leader – it’s time for Musharraf to go. He has shown himself to be an opportunist and incompetent. The poor kids in the Lal Masjid are still our people- good or bad. Months ago the government should have acted to close off the area around the school and encourage the students inside to leave. He kept the drama going on for so long for political mileage. He wants to show everyone in the West” Hey if not for me, look what will happen to this country”.If not for the abduction of the Chinese, he probably would have left the Lal Masjid alone for longer. China remains Pakistan’s only true friend and even an uneducated dictator like Musharraf realized that the Chinese could not be offended. It’s disgusting that he views Pakistani lives so cheaply. The death of even one Pakistani student is too a price to pay for Musharraf’s incompetence. With all of the aid money the West is providing to fight terrorism cannot the Army spend more on proper schools and insitutions for our kids. It’s wasted on corrupt generals and their pet projects. If Musharraf has any shame he should step down before he damages the nation more.
7072007
moon shah(22:31:53) :
this should be done earlier
7072007
moon shah(22:33:41) :
how cheap the ghazi brothers .they are taking advantage of small boys and girls
7072007
sima(23:39:53) :
…
The situation is very sensitive and critical between Government and jameha Hifza.
who is rite and who is wrong this is another matter but why they trapped innocent lives in that cage.
So sad situation for muslims.
now we can easily imagine that the day of Judment is not so far.
but this time the Government is helpless infact not helpless they can do bitter operation they have power but they cant just becoz of innocent guys and women who are inside jamieha.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
as a muslim
.
.
we have to pray for all ppl who r inside and in great trouble……
ALLAH un ko apne hifzo Amaan main rakhey Amin…..
8072007
Javed Abbas(00:20:37) :
It is important to find out that how and where are these so called students in Lal Musjid are getting their arms and ammounitions, who is funding their efforts.
8072007
Javed Abbas(00:30:25) :
Go Musharaf go, clean this mess up, these; so called students are not loyal to the country of Pakistan, you know which country are their leaders are loyal to and are funded. Do not hazitate, level the ground, we can build another Mosque right away at the same spot.
Musharaf you have support, its just most of the your supporters are honarable and piece loving people and do not want to take time to defend your efforts.
Go Musharaf GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
8072007
Saima Gul(00:36:13) :
All of the supporters of these Students / Mullahs in Lal Musjid, I have one simple questions. “Where did these guys get Arms from”. Try to find the answer to this questions and you will understand what is going on and who is behind this. This is not the end of it, I guarantee you we will see more.
Saima Gul
8072007
Imtiaz Khan(00:43:17) :
Kick their butts and put them all away for a long period of time. They do not deserve to be a Pakistani. Shame on all of us of not taking care of these people earlier. Send them back where they all came from.
8072007
Anonymous(10:35:36) :
If Pres Musharaf have some proof regarding the use of lal masjid for terriorism, he must show it on media, before any major operation. this will avoid further policicall issue violance in country
8072007
Anonymous(10:35:59) :
If Pres Musharaf have some proof regarding the use of lal masjid for terriorism, he must show it on media, before any major operation. this will avoid further policicall issue violance in country
AHA
8072007
Sher Kohh(11:12:54) :
Sab se Pehle Islam
Not
Sub se Pehle Pakistan
Any way Our GREAT PAK ISLAMIC ARMY once again Concoring their own country
caz they ONY can This type of shit
PAkistan Se Zinda Bhag
8072007
Ally(11:53:06) :
IN SITUATION LIKE THIS TRUST ME I WILL NEVER ATTACK A MOSQUE ATLEAST, UNLESS I AM A PUPPET TO A FOREIGN POWER. I WILL LET ALL OF THEM IN THE MOSQUE VICINITY GO FREE UNTILL THE TIME I CATCH EXACTLY THE PERSON IF I HAVE TO WITHOUT ANY BLOOD SHED AND BIG SHOW LIKE THIS. A NON BELIEVER IS FREE THIS WORLD IS JANNAT FOR HIM AND WE PAKISTAN MUSLIMS ARE NOT TAKING PRIDE IN OUR KALIMAH AND THE SUNNAT TARIQA AND TRYING TO FOLLOW THE WEST.
THIS PERVEZ IS A WARNER AZAB OF ALLAH FOR US TO CHANGE OUR LIVES ACCORDING TO ISLAM.
SOME PEOPLE DIE IN BED AND SOME ON THE ROAD EVENTUALLY EVERYONE DIES SO LET US BE GOOD MUSLIMS AND BE EXAMPLERY MUSLIMS AND DIE WITH KALIMAH. EVEN FOR PERVEZ MUSHARAF TO MAKE HIM A TRUE MUSLIM AND LEADER. FOR THAT WE HAVE TO CHANGE OURSELVES FIRST. ALLAH SENDS HIS AZAAB IN DIFFERENT FORMS TO CORRECT US IN THIS WORLD INSTEAD OF PUTTING US IN THE FIRE OF HELL, “WHICH SURELY WOULD NOT GIVE ANY BENEFIT TO ALLAH TABARAK WATALLAH”.
SO LET US TURN TO ALLAH AND FOLLOW THE SUNNAT TARIQA, AND STOP INTERNAL PROBLEMS IN THE COUNTRY, ALLAH WISHES OUR LIFE AND DEATH WILL BE SUCCESSFUL.
8072007
Ally(11:56:45) :
LET US MAKE DUA TO ALLAH TABARAK WATALLAH, WITH OUR FIVE TIME CORRECT SALLAH.
HE SURELY IS MOST MERCIFUL.
AMEEN.
I hope the good people of Pakistan defeat these Taliban types, inshalla…
absurd thought -
God of the Universe says
let extremists rule
they will drag your country
back to seventh century
.
8072007
Haider Naqvi(15:32:00) :
is it possible that such a big war preparation took place in a mosque in the middle of islamabad in the presence of an intelligience organization like ISI who has played a major role in defeating U S S R ?
8072007
Shah(18:47:07) :
We r Muslims Not Terrorist …Gr8 Job Musharaf
Khallas….!!!
9072007
Lughmani(00:07:44) :
hmmm interesting comments…..ok what i think is that those mulla’s goals are genuine…infact every one wants islamic law in this country…but the procedure to achieve those goals very not lawfull….they should be trying to deliever their messege to everyone PEACEFULLY…..i think that was the right procedure of spreading islam….
“REMEMBER …. IF WE WANT THIS COUNTRY TO MOVE IN RIGHT DIRECTION…..WE SHOULD MAKE SURE …. THAT EVERYONE OBEY THE LAW”
9072007
MUSLIM...(03:05:22) :
Look at how low and shameless the Pakistani govt has proved themselves as… Killing alims, alimas, hafiz n hafizas, the leaders of the Muslims tomorrow and the strong hold of the Muslim Ummah, all because some haram prostitutes declared that their rights have been violated – or maybe the Pakistani govt sees it as their own ‘duty’ to honour these filthy women by bringing them justice, from the restrictions Shariah, OUR Belief, and OUR Lord places on them??
They’ve had months to close down them brothels, massage parlours, and music shops.
The students of Laal Masjid who yes, have alhamdulila decided to take the Islamic Law into their own more worthy hands, because the government has disregarded it for so long. But they didn’t listen, didn’t take heed, so what do they expect?
You might say both are in the wrong, but do u know that 325 students have been shaheed early morning today?! And no, even though imam ghazi has asked and requested, the Great Muslim Army has prevented any journalists from entering and seeing the damage. And so, unless u saw the broadcast in the morning with the interview with imam ghazi, u wont hear about that again. The utter shame and disgrace!
All due respect to the army and their supposed heroism, but if they die fighting against those who attempted to uphold the deen and the laws of Allah, can you imagine the state they will be raised up on on the day of qiyamah?
May Allah give martyrdom or victory to His true servants, in both cases, they’re successful. And to quote a female student of laal masjid, ‘we’ve worn our kaffans, and we’re ready’ and as imam ghazi said yesterday, ‘the students say we have done nothing wrong, and say they will never bow down before firawn’. That’s the strength this ummah needs.
9072007
asif(12:57:17) :
I do not support extremisim, but when these people were fighting against Russia, they were world’s heroes and now, all of us are against them. If you use some one for a porpuse and then turn against him then he would be extremist against you.
My personal belief is that in future any muslim who will ask for an islamic society will be treated like a militant or extremist. So muslims must prepare to accept the fate of shameful western culture or face the hard actions from their own guards.
9072007
nawaz(13:40:24) :
we hate musharraf because he is doing this drama just to keep hidden the case of chief justice as well as APC and may be he will do some more behind this. musharraf will also do like this when he needs and tomorrow he will start fight against any pakistani area. ALLAH give him Hedayat if there is no Hedayat for him then ALLAH funishe him very soon.
9072007
Nadir(14:47:49) :
Maulana Abdur Rasheed Ghazi is a soldier of Islam and fighting in the way of Allah. I ask the people here in this forum, what’s wrong if the Lal Masjid people struggling for Allah’s (SWT) rule in this country? With what aim we got freedom in 1947? Our slogan was, “Pakistan ka matlab kia, La Illaha Ill-Allah”. what does this mean? This means that there should be a place where Muslims could live their lives according to their religion. It was not possible living with India, so our demand was justified by the famous slogan mentioned above. Then after the independence, we forgot our cause of separation from India. Our ancestors sacrificed their lives for their dreams of an Islamic state. Is this an Islamic state? What is the sin that is not done in this so-callad “Mumlikat-e-Khudadad”? There are Vine shops in this country, porn CD/DVD shops in this country, prostitution is a common practice in this country, half naked women on the huge billboards/banners in this country, murderers are rulers in our country, one who has power can do whatever he wants and there is no law for him……..These are countless. So my fellow Muslim Brothers and sisters, only SHARIAH LAW can protect us from these sins. It is due to our sin that Allah has cursed us with the present corrupt rulers. Do you see what they are doing with the Lal Masjid Mujahideen(may Allah bless them all), their crime is that they are struggling for Allah’s law. Injustice in our country could only be ended by Allah’s rule. O! My fellow Muslim brothers and sisters, I request you to please analyze the current situation and think what is going on. Don’t believe just what the rulers say, use your mind also. if the government is true in all its claims, then why it is not allowing the media to go inside th “Lal Masjid”? Think upon it. It is all occuring because they see their end and end of their corruption in Allah’s law. Thank You.
9072007
m waqar(17:30:37) :
Maulana Abdur Rasheed Ghazi is not a soldier of Islam,he is a terrorist,a criminal and he should be shot and hang his body in Islamabad.
9072007
Mahmood(18:41:03) :
Nadir I don’t think matters are as black and white as you present. I don’t support the government because it too is illegal and unconstitutional. Musharraf is the biggest embarrassment for Pakistan because he makes our country look like a Banana Republic ruled by the military. He comes across as an illiterate and uneducated man in the West – and not only because he is so poor in spooken English. He used the Lal Masjid folks for his own purposes and now he wants to pull the plug. It’s a shame that it has come to this.I want Pakistan to get back to a functioning democracy where there is rule of law for all. However the folks in the Lal Masjid were clearly taking the law into their own hands. Initially they were encouraged by Musharraf so he could show the world what he was up against but then after the incident with the Chinese he was forced to stop them. Musharraf is a criminal becasue he cares so little about Pakistan and her people. As for all the vice in Pakistan -Can we not fight against the injustices in Pakistan through peaceful means. By all means demonstrate outside stores where you feel porno is being sold or stop patronizing hotels where you believe there is prositution or boycotting restaurants where the owners are serving alcohol and drugs. Pakistanis are not Arabs or Afghanis or Iranians- despite our leaders the common people have a tradition of working for things in a civilized way through discussion and dialogue
10072007
SK(08:26:10) :
These maulvis have no purpose left in life but to brainwash people and to try to take over the world. GET REAL. Islam is not about just spreading Islam. Its more about creating a balance in life, understanding life, and making the most of what we have in this world. These people have turned into maniacs, psychos with a lost cause.
Why can they not work on making themselves better “Muslim” first, before they go about and try to take an entire nation under their control? And even if they are given control, what is the guarantee that even under Shariah law these rulers will not have personal interests conflicting with Shariah rule?
As far as Musharaff is concerned, regardless of his political stance, what matters is that right now he is on the verge of cleaning out a cancerous cell, and this is important before it spreads in the entirety.
Yeh khud hee gunehgar hain joh masoom jaanon koh kabzay mein rakhay huay hain, aur dhamkaa rahay hain. Upar say kehtay hain kay government masoom jaanain ley rahi hay. Yeh naubat hee nahi aati agar inki be-tuqi farmayeshein naa hoteen…
ALLAH TALLAH IN MAULVION KOH AQAL DEIN. AMEEN.
10072007
SK(08:31:59) :
I also agree with Mahmood and m waqar.
Nadir, a real soldier of Islam would be against what is happening. Did anyone ever think that a holy and beautiful place as a masjid (House of ALLAH SWT) would ever be ground for war? La haula wala quwat. A real soldier of Islam would promote peace and just put and end to chaos. These are not soldiers but enemies of Islam, they just do not realize that. They are creating barriers within Islam and breaking it apart.
I request that you think of it for a second, just apart from what everyone argues, just use your brain. Think hard, apart from what Islam “tells” us it is about. Think for yourself, what is Islam about. QUESTION IT!!! QUESTION and DOUBT ISLAMIC principles and you will find the REAL ISLAM! Look inside your heart, not at what others tell you and brainwash you. If this was to make things better, they would have been better. But for past few years things have been getting worse and worse and worse. Musalman mooh dikhanay layak nahi rahay. Khud hee dekho khud hee socho.
As Mufti Taqi Saheb db said, the demands and motives were praiseworthy, however the tactic were not good.
Those who say that its a good thing musharraf is doing so, I ask in light of humane morality,
Is prostitution good? Is the filth of Fahsh (explicit) movies good? Is destruction of mosque good? Why didnt the govt do their responsibility even after complaints were given to the “law of land”
and in this particular case, is it any beneficial to do military action while Mr. Ghazi etc were willing to cooperate only if a safe passage is given…
The question is, which actions do we see more islamic? Shahadat in Islam or Liying to your children.. that I think will explain our true motives. Dont get me wrong, but a masjid is being torn to pieces.. I will not care of the context but to save the house of Allah alone be willing to say out loud to stop this atrocity!
Wassalam
10072007
sayeda sana(16:40:30) :
if some says that molana is spreading islam but i think and most of them agree with me that it is totally wrong way of spreading islam
how can it spread in this way?
and jehad does’nt mean to kill people………..
and i think v r own responsible of making our image bad around the globe by doing all these whether it is done by Molana or Musharaf……………………….
and the escape of the honour of the Mosque in wearing BURQA is vvvv shame full 4 all muslims…………
if they want to surrender then should be just like a men not by weraing BURQA …………
by doing this he leave not agood example for reamining ones inside the mosque………………….
10072007
Muhammad Asghar Durrani(16:49:43) :
Dear All,
Its not a points scoring game, we all should think about the root cause of all the unrest in our country and around the muslim world. The only solution to these issues is chosing the right path of islam. We should not just waste our time by blaming Musharraf or Moulana Brothers. We must have to think about the negative consequences and to prepare our self to combat with the repercusions. Everyone has the right of expression but we should look and study the circumstances. Always be positive.
We are giving opportunity to our so-called WELL WISHERS to laugh on us and to divide us as much as they can. We’re really in trouble and going thru a very very tough time of our history. Its not only the issue of Lal Masjid, Aunti Shamim, Library or Massage centres. But its an issue and problem of our country, province, city and our home. NAd I’m sure nobody will want to see their home like that.
10072007
U Siddiqui(17:17:36) :
So to say the mosque is being attacked. How conveniently the world is getting the impression that the people inside are traitors, culprits, terrorists. What has not surfaced is the fact that the two leaders that started this coo are ISI agents acting as Mr. Musharaf puppets. Their ultimate goal; eliminate all the madrasas in Islamabad, fill hated among the people for din and create a police state where no sect will be able to practice their beliefs openly. Shame on such people, one day you will face Allah and he will then decide what your ultimate fate will be.
10072007
Safeer(17:30:29) :
A shameful attempt to deceive the West and USA…! Human rights organizations must take notice. A military dictator should not be let to keep on at the cost of lives of innocent citizens. Blood of Ladies and children is being used to fuel the illegitimate Musharraf regime. Can USA and West be inspired by this drama which has many flaws if we have a closer look at it? Civil administration and mosque administration touched a peaceful solution many times but always sabotaged by the military regime. “Shoot at sight” orders for media personnel at the time of final operation tells that military regime wants to hid the facts from pubic and international media.
10072007
Shah(18:48:25) :
According to my point of view, all the political parties that are in exile and in Pakistan are united and behind this. They are using the extremists to breakdown Musharaf’s leadership. These extremists and the ignorant burden of Pakistani society should be warned to get back on normal track, if not, there’s no other solution than getting them all together and burning them all!
11072007
Zafar(00:48:59) :
Aaj K iss Wakia per Mujay Bohat e
dukh k saath kehna per raha hay k Govt nay operation ker diya or Govt k daway jotay niklay k hum waha per bayguna auraton or Bachon ko bachana chatay hain. Laykin esa nai huwa Q k baz kowatain masliat cha ti e nai thi. may yaha yeh nai kehna chata k Lal Masjid walay teek thay ya unhoon nay acha kia. agar govt chati tho wo yeh masla hal kr sakti thi or govt k haath may tha k wo inn logon ko bcha sakti thi magar govt ki america nawaz policy or Hadarmi ki waja say itni logon ki janay gawai. Allah in sub ko Janat ul Firdos may jaga dey Aamin. Or agar govt un ko safe passege b deh dehti tho mera nai kiyal ko wo govt ki nazro say door hotay. Govt un logo ko badh may b arrest kr sakti thi or hamari agencies ko tho her eik cheez ki kabar hoti hay. Or agar govt ka yeh mokaf a k yeh log mulk k liyeh khatra hain tho mera kiyal k iss waqat Govt may jitnay b hukumran hain wo apnay gareban may jank kr dekhy k kia wo mulk k liyeh katra nai or un per bayguna logo k katal k mukadimat b hain or sub sy baray tho hamray mulk k liyeh katra tho iss waqat hamaray Hukumran hain.
11072007
shariq(01:55:42) :
Army took right step….which was very necessary to resolve this influence against the Muslims enemy….
11072007
Nadir(02:02:52) :
At last, Maulana Abdur Rasheed Ghazi and other Mujahideen have been martyred. May Allah be pleased with them all and let them enter the Paradise for their Shahada. Maulana Ghazi spoke for truth and got perished for it. If anyone analyzes what he said to the media at different times regarding the current crisis, he will found no contradiction in his talks, and it is a fake allegation by the Govt. that he changes his statements continuously. Maulana Ghazi and his elder brother were deceived by the Govt. who did not negotiated sincerely with these brothers. Yesterday, when our respected clerics were trying to resolve this situation through peaceful means and there had been prepared a draft for it and Maulana Ghazi and the ministers with the help of clerics were very near of the peaceful resolution, musharraf interrupted and amended in that draft which ended all these negotiations. He always wants to deal with any situation through gun-point. He likes bloodshed and wants to ruin our country through his dictatorship. Even media personnel are restricted to practice their duties honestly.
in the end I will request people here to make a Dua’a for these Shaheed Mujahideen, and also to get rid of Mr. President.
11072007
Mahmood(02:15:54) :
I too am disappointed to see the unecessary loss of life in the Lal Masjid debacle. It is an embarrassment for Pakistan and shows the incompetence of Musharraf and his dictatorship. This whole matter could have been settled long ago through peaceful means. It’s all a political drama and the poor students have been manipulated by the government and the Mullahs. I’ve said this before : the people in the Lal Masjid are our fellow Pakistanis- they were duped by both the military and the Mosque leaders. We need to create real educational opportunities for our fellow citizens. As for these Maddrasahs I’m sorry there is no role for any type of vigilante actions. Just because Musharraf disrespects the laws of Pakistan doesn’t mean other Pakistanis have the right to take the law into their own hands. Let’s learn to fight for our beliefs through constitutional and legal means. We might just strengthen our institutions and create a civil society in the process- the progressive social democratic Islamic state envisioned by Iqbal!
OPERATION SILENCE STARTED on 4:40 AM 10 july 2007
LALMASJID BREAKFAST: BOMBS n BLOODSHED
MOLANA AR GHAZI, HIS MOTHER n 700 ISLAMIC MILITANTS KILLED
AMERICA APPRECIATES MUSJARRAF ON WAR AGAINST EXTREMISM
MUSHARRAF CHANGED THE DRAFT: M RAFI USMANI
OPERATION SILENCE CONTINUES AT NIGHT
15 SECURITYMEN KILLED n HUNDREDS WOUNDED
DEATHS ARE NOT BEING SHOWN TO MEDIA BCOZ ARMY KILLED WOMEN n CHILDREN INSIDE
NO INJURED PEOPLE FROM RED MOSQUE ADMITTED IN HOSPITALS: PAKISTAN MEDIA
MORE THAN 140 BOMBS USED IN COMBAT
SHUJAT, DURANI, EJAZULHAQ n TARIQAZEEM DISAPPOINTED FROM DIALOGUES
VERY DISAPPOINTMENT FROM PAKISTAN PEOPLE EXCEPT BENAZIR BHUTTO
X ARMY CHEIF MIRZA ASLAM BAIG CONDEMNS MUSHARRAF ACTION
GOVT SAYS THERE ARE FORIGNERS INSIDE: WHY GOVT TAKE U TURN?
WE HAVENOT KILLED, RAPED n ANY OTHER CRIME SO WHY WE ARE BEING PUNISHED? THIS COUNTRY WILL BE A MUSLIM STATE ONE DAY AMIN: LAST TALK OF MOLANA ABDUL RASHID GHAZI (shaheed?) WITH MEDIA
AFTER EFFECTS?
MUSHARRAF AND ARMY KILLED WOMEN AND CHILDREN IN OPERATION SILENCE AT LAL MASJID RED MOSQUE ISLAMABAD PAKISTAN.
THEY DID NOT ALLOW ANY MEDIA MAN TO KNOW WHAT WAS THEY DOING THERE.
cooolstar
11072007
A Khan(05:04:32) :
Dear Fellow Pakistanis, Before everyone starts beating the “ISLAMIC DRUM” and portraying as the best Muslims hence declaring all others, “moderates”, KAFIRS, why don’t you take a little test of your own Islamic knowledge. The question is in our society what percentage approves of a marriage with an “ahle-kitab”? Answer this to yourself, I would guess your answer would range from 70% to a 100%. Now please answer that of those people that accept such a marriage, how many will be willing to eat a regular McDonald’s beef burger in the West (since such a burger is said to be haram)? I would guess the answer to range in atleast 60% to 80% of those who accept the ahle-kitab marriage. Now are you guys ready for THE shock of your life, go to any library / mosque and pick at least 5 Qurans, read Sura Al-Maeda Ayat 5, here is a link to online translation http://www.usc.edu/dept/MSA/quran/005.qmt.html
The Quran clearly states that both the food and women (in marriage) of ahle-kitab are halal now think of it this way, why did our Islamic “SCHOLARS” only made the food haram and women halal (of ahle-kitab). Can it be to satisfy the greater animal urge that women of ahle-kitab were made halal and food (the lesser of urge under normal circumstances) made haram. Listening to what Allah has said in Quran, either they should both be halal or both be haram, there is no room for exclusion or extortion of Al-Maeda no. 5 as its logic requires no tafseer. The words used are women, food, halal, haram, all these words are extremely common in Quran thus no linguistic problem can be there either. My intent is to show you the extent hypo-criticism in our society.
My dear brothers and sisters in Islam, we have a book that was sent to us from Allah, please take it out of the covers and start reading it and you would come to know that you do not need MAULANA ABDUL RASHEED GHAZI to teach you Islam. Islam teaches patience and not torching of government buildings and vehicles. If any one of you can find an instance where a house of a non-Muslim was burnt EVER in the times of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), the answer will be NO.
Now at the end let me give you all a little time-line of how we Pakistanis got to the shameful occurring of the last week. In 1977, Prime Minister ZA Bhutto, took out the genie of radicalism (please do not mix islam with radicalism and terrorism by calling it Islamic radicalism, there is no such thing) by politicizing religion and drawing a clear line through our already divided society by banning alcohol, oh by the way wasn’t Bhutto a ‘fish’ when it came to drinking himself? Then came the doomed era of Zia-ul-Haq (the reason I do not write General is that 99% of our Army is same people as you and me and only 1% are the real problem the people on top). Zia used religion for his own vested interests and for the interests of everyone else. The genie grew. Then came Ms. Bhutto, who claims to be the biggest liberal of Pakistan but forgets that it was during her time that Taliban were created under the due supervision of Mr. Nasir Ullah Babar and if she tries to tell her that Taliban were created by ISI, please ask her why did she not resign, if she was so powerless? As for Nawaz Sharif and other Mulla lot, we all know the foundries and the diesel permits and all. Then came Mr. Musharaf, he is not much different than others either however the only problem is that yesterday he tried to go after the genie that has been fed and blown out of proportion since 1977. Let us all pray for ALL those who died and lets also pray that our shameful leaders on both sides of the divide get some fear of Allah (the one mentioned in Quran). Allah Hafiz.
11072007
aysha(10:38:11) :
salam
aap kisi ha ?
i think gen. musharaf did what he must did a long time before .
we want peace
we want a country without terror and violence
we want a country without taliban
i like to tell it is the time we cut the usa and saudi arabi hands and support of taliban
INA LILLAH HAY WA INA ILLAIHAY RAJAOON. ALLAH molana gazi rasheed (shaheed) ko is ajar to zarror day ga lakin hamaray liya ya nasihat hay kay un logon nay kis liya ya sab qurbaniyan dee sirf islam ko mulak main phalanay kay liya. lakin hum log sirf batain he kar saktay hain bus or kuch nah. kya wo log galat kar rahay thay go kuch islamabad main chinesse massage center main ho raha tha lakin afsson hay hamain apnay app per. or hadis ka mahfoom hay kay jab log naiki ka hukam danay or burai say rokna chor dain gay to bohot buray hukmran tum per ban jain gay. ( Tirmizi Shareef ) . or ab ap khud he dakh lain jo kuch ho raha hay. Afssos hay is bat per. ap ya socain kay GHAZI ABUL RASHEED SHAHEED KAY nam kay shuru main gazi or end per shaheed a gaya. wah gazi abdul rasheed shaheed g ap or ap kay sathiyon per sallam.
11072007
Shah(14:29:50) :
A good citizen of world thinks regardless of religion, race and color. If you can’t give positive and liberal point of view, don’t write down extremism supporting bullshit comments. We needed leader like Musharaf long time before. Enough of Arab influence on Pakistani culture, it has to end up! Our society needs broad minded people judging people not with their religions, colors and nationalities but as a person. Islam is not as complicated as these Mulla guys have made in Pakistan.
11072007
Mahmood(17:44:47) :
I agree that Islam is not a complicated religion and that some of our Mullahs are misguided. However the last thing we need is an illiterate and incompetent leader like Musharraf who stumbles from one problem to the next. It’s not just that Musharraf comes across like a clown in the world with no authority. The military has a job: defend the borders of Pakistan- not to involve itself with managing the country. He has taken the professionalism away from the Pakistan Army and engrossed the army in corruption. Transparency International (European Think Tank) rates the Musharraf government more corrupt than either BB government or Nawaz Sharif. My friend we are all Pakistan- forget about individual leaders- let’s talk about creating institutions and systems where we are all collectively building our beloved Pakistan. Let’s not look for leaders and heros to save us- we can save ourselves by starting to respect our laws and constitution. Let’s bring back any form of democracy before the ignorance of Musharraf causes more damage.
11072007
Shah(18:49:12) :
Although it’s unfair for military to involve in managing the countries politics but what have the politicians before Musharaf given to us EXCEPT corruption, poverty and freedom of practicing extremism in terms of religion. You are right we all have to build up future of this country but not with involving religion into Politics: by not imposing the sharia law. Arab influence and their sponsorship for making Pakistan little Saudi Arabia has to stop. And for controlling all this corruption, extremism and ignorance I think you can’t have somebody better than Musharaf. FULL STOP
11072007
Mobin Mushtaq(22:50:51) :
I think General Pervaiz Musharaf was forced by the Militants to take extreme steps of use of force inside a mosque. We being muslims should be ashamed of the fact that our Religious Teachers who claim to be doing Jehad are using women and childrens as a sheild. Any one that can take a weapon inside a mosque or have bombs stored inside a mosque should not be considered a Shaheed / Martyr. This situation was created by Islamic Extremists and outside forces that do not want political stability in Pakistan. Sharia law is used as a cover to create instability in the country.
I just hope that we all can see this and agree that Islam does not teach all this. I hope that after this operation the Government and specially General Musharaf would clean up the Red Mosque area and do necessary repairs or rebuild the Mosque and hopefully place people in the mosque that actually preach Islam and not violence.
We as a country have suffered enough due to inside forces that work against our country. Its about time that we progress and show the world that we are not a third world country anymore.
12072007
Mahmood(00:04:01) :
Shah why not ask impartial agencies around the world how they grade the military in Pakistan- our corruption ranking under Musharraf is worse than either BB or Nawaz Sharif! As for our economic and health indices they are just as dismal. This despite all the aid we are getting for the so called war on terror. Nawaz or BB didn’t receive the loot that Musharraf is getting from the West. Ultimately we have to return to a democratic dispensation with strong institutions. If Musharraf has any respect for the military or Pakistan he should step down now and return the country to elected leaders- good or bad that is our destiny- not to be ruled by an illiterate incompetent like Musharraf!
Years of Musharraf rule has brought ridicule to Pakistan on the world stage; Do you not remember the Washingtom Post headlines when he was caught in his own lies. First claiming that women in Pakistan were purposely getting themselves raped to get immigration and then denying he would say such a stupid thing. The newspaper (Washington Post)simply released the recording of him saying the very words he denied saying. I am too much a Pakistani to let our nation remain as a military dictatorship/Banana Republic with someone like Musharraf at the helm.
12072007
Shah(14:08:04) :
Mahmood, no leader in the entire world history has been perfect and perhaps won’t be but you can see their work done with comparing them with each other and the progress they’ve made in their time. You can’t just be chief of army staff if you are illiterate. There are times when military powers are necessary to control the situation in country, otherwise Muhammad Ali Jinnah wouldn’t have asked for a new country on the basis of uncontrollable religious discrimination and extermism. Even though it was more about gaining leadership because a non-religious man drinking alcohol has got to have a purpose behind asking for a new country for Muslims ONLY. The problem with our country’s is that our candidates for presidency are corrupt so it’s unsafe to give away country in such hands by playing the election drama once again. It’s also unrealistic to think of Pakistan without Musharraf and freedom of religious extremism at the same time. Elected candidates just can’t control it this way.
12072007
Mahmood(17:29:06) :
Shah, Jinnah established and secured Pakistan through patently constitutional means- he was a lawyer and man of principle who envisioned Pakistan as a functioning democracy. (I’m not talking about his personal habits or lifestyle)If you look back there are several instances in which he explicity spoke of the military’s role as being subservient to the elected executive. As for extremsim and religious discrimination, I believe such social ills are fostered under the military set up. Read the New York Times analysis and the Washington Post analysis of the last two days. Both refer to increasing instability under the current dictatorship beacause a military ruler such as Musharraf has no moral authority to lead a consitutional democracy. We don’t need to control anyone in Pakistan- we need to educate our fellow citizens and develop institutions. Why are so many Pakistanis successful in other parts of the world when we find it so difficult to succeed at home- it’s not for lack of talent but because we have yet to respect institutions. Tell me honestly, if another army officer were to walk into the Presidential suite and kick out Musharraf we would all say it’s unlawful but who’s to stop it. People like Musharraf have done it so why shouldn’t anyone else. At some point we have to get on with the exercise of democracy. Incidentally I do think that Musharraf is a fucntional illiterate apart from being incompetent. Trust me we’ve had many Chiefs of Army staff who have been incompetent if you look back. Musharraf was made Chief by Nawaz Sharif superceding even more senior Generals becasue the latter thought him pliant- just like Bhutto did with Zia. I Hope that this time the dictator is charged in court to send a clear message to other usurpers of civil society not to interfere in government. So it goes but I pray for Pakistan and for the development of institutions.
12072007
Hameed(17:58:31) :
How is it possible that the lal masjid students are armed, although the madrassa is in the capital under supervision of ISI? might this was the plan of isi.
12072007
Pakiboy(21:40:13) :
AAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!
12072007
Sher Kohh(23:48:40) :
Just Tell Me Two Things
Did ever our Army wins a battle
1948, 1965, 1971, Sia Chin, Kargil ????????????
They Only can concure their own country and can Kill their fellow country men.
Second What is the defination of Shaheed
what i read is ” Who Dies for Allah and Islam is called Shaheed”
the soldiers killed in this mosque attack are they realy shaheed?
13072007
Mahmood(02:29:34) :
I think that the conversation is getting a bit of topic. Our Army may not have decisively win any war but we kept our much bigger neighbour at bay in 1948 and 1965. As for the limited skirmish at the Rann of Kutch most observers say we were winning but our own leaders slowed things down. I often wonder whether a better strategy would have improved the outcome of the 1965 war since things were intially going in our favour. I am from Sialkot district and my parents and grandparents always spoke proudly of the military and the sacrifices made especially at the battle of Chawinda. Although we lost the 1971 war our hands were tied due to the political incompetence of military leaders and the rebellion. Otherwise our military has remained a formidable deterrent agaisnt aggression by our more powerful neighbours. We should never dismiss the role of our military in safegaurding our sovereignty but it should have no role in running our country. Musharraf himself is responsible for tarnishing the image and professionalism of the Pakistani military. I know it’s hard to support the military when they try to restore law and order against groups such as the Lal Masjid. It’s not the fault of the rank and file soldiers or jawans that the Generals and Musharraf are corrupt and incompetent. Getting back to your original point maybe a dedicated SWAT team formed from police units would be better to deal with this type of challenge instead of the Pakistani Army.
13072007
Liaquat Ali(07:08:00) :
I agree that lal masjid folks took law into own hands but they did highlight failure of law and order. Islamabad is full of brothels and alcohol is freely available. The authorities have been knocking down masjids to grab prime land which they will from lal masjid too since you probably heard precursor words that buildings occupied government land.
Remember kargil, unprovoked war , guess who was leading that , yes general saab. He has also given alcohol licenses to ministers in view of legalizing it since baba bush only visits countries which server him his favorite.
Comments from people are so alarming and based on media lies spread by government. Arms were given by government no doubt and the later display is joke , if they had rockets and other heavy arms, why didn’t they use them, were they saving them for life after death.
Another comment on talk failures, government say he was buying time, my question is time for what ?, he had no water no electric bad air running out of food ..He was buying more time for what?
Real answer was the day they were declared militants from students, not many of you noticed the change in wording but what it meant was they should be killed since its American term for license to kill.
All I can say is if government can do its job no lal masjid case would ever happen. By the way shame on government that they had to ask Edhi trust for ambulances, they are so corrupt that they don’t even have own resources to handle minor disasters of own creating.
For those of you praising military shame on you since military has always taken all of your resources for themselves, just go and look at their complexes. As for protection, well loosing half of the country and loosing most of Kashmir, I am sure we could have negotiated better deal with India without arms.
The whole case, I wont call it operation , came from CIA book, its been used in Iraq , Afghanistan etc. i.e. how to make negotiations fail so you can attack , remember Sadam and Taliban, they never did anything to Americans well may be didn’t give cheap drugs and cheap oil!!!
13072007
Worried Paki(11:03:20) :
Thus proved…………. “Every thing is fair in love n power”
If person who “KIDNAPPED” three women can be treated like this, what about about a person who had “KIDNAPPED” 150 Million innocent people?
Most horrifing thing that is developing among the country men is the “INCREASING HATRED FOR PAK ARMY”………. just becoz of one person.
Please be pathetic to this beautiful country………let the democray florish, otherwise Americans prediction of ” NO PAKISTAN ON EARTH IN YEAR 2012″ may become true.
13072007
inam(12:49:19) :
Ina lilla wa ina alehe rajiooon
Please pray for Shaheed Abul Rasheed Ghazi & all Shuhada of LAL Mosque fought for implementation of islam till shahadat,
Their way might be right or wrong, but their aim was to implement Islamic Laws in this country regardless of any personal benifits & anyone fought for islam to be implemented, weather they were in majority or minority & they prefer shahadat insted of stepping back, have an honour of Shaheed in this world & next.
(They do not want a Nishan-e-Haider, they have high values in front of Allah)
Allah know all right & wrongs.
Please recite 1-time Alhamdulillah rabul alameen complete & 3-time Quil howallah complete & pray for shudada of Islam.
Muslims are brothers. Make a brotherhood
Please forward after u pray for Shahada.
13072007
calshah@gmail.com(13:19:18) :
Dudes like inam need to live in Saudi Arabia NOT in Pakistan!
13072007
Shah(13:19:41) :
Dudes like Inam need to live in Saudi Arabia NOT in Pakistan!
13072007
Mahmood(15:16:40) :
I am not pleased whenever there is any loss of life in Pakistan; they are all our people from the soldier who is following orders to the brainwashed kids inside the madressas. We need to have proper schools and opportunities for our kids. Perhaps we should direct more of our resources to education and the strenghtening of insitutions but our leadership is corrupt from the top. Look at Musharraf’s Book tour- taking Pakistani state money to go on a trip to promote a book while you are sitting as a President. I agree that Musharraf is giving the Pakistani Army a bad name. The sooner he leabes the better but people like him need to be put on trial for treason agaisnt the state and consitution to send a clear message to the next fellow who wants to illegally seize power.
13072007
Believer(20:35:17) :
I pray that the souls of all the martyers of the Lal mosque are in peace, I ask that their families are blessed with peace and tranquilty.
The recent horrific assult on the Lal Mosque was a repeat of History-Many Karbala’s have been witnessed by the Muslims, over the enturies and this is a nother reminder
Water being cut off, electricity being cut, unbearable heat of the summer, surrounded by barbed wire and troops with high powered weapons helicopters tanks, who were they trying to defeat?
The Yazid’s orders for his troops were to kill them ALL. Does this statement sound familiar? As this story is of Karbala, those who were beloved, gave up their life for their Creator. From Him we came and to Him we will return. troops versus the poor thrreialt
13072007
Muslimma(20:57:47) :
Before we comment we shouls know the TRUTH.
1) The Ghazi has agreed several minutes before the first bombing to a peaceful settlement (check with ministers and his mobile phone conversation) and asked all media be present to listen to this agreement
2)As his mother lay dying in his lap, he said to the ministers there is no turning back
3) Those who wanted to leave left, those who wanted to be SHAHEED stayed
4) No Water, Electricity etc for many of those inside
5) No help for the wounded Women and Children
6) Check out the Video footage of what occurred on each night after they bombed the Mosque-Yes Lightning, Fast wind and Heavey Rain
7)Government reports contrdicting their won statements-i.ethey had finger printed all those that had passed away, but admit that many bodies burnt so badly that they could not be identified! Additional 800 requests for coffins from EDHI foundation? Why and for whom?
9) Why did the Bushraffe order Bombing at night? Is this so you could not hear or see the screems of women and children? and their innocent blood running out of the Mosque?
14072007
Kashif Khan(12:18:16) :
i think this fight betveen muslims and so-cald muslim and i also thought muslims win
on 1st night of lal masjid student and abdul rashid gazi in grave skay cry (roya or chilaya) yani us ko bhi dukh hua.
Please pray for Shaheed Abul Rasheed Ghazi & all Shuhada of LAL Mosque fought for implementation of islam till shahadat,
14072007
Sher Kohh(12:35:10) :
Mr. Mahmood,
you gave the example of Chowindah you know when one of our general proudly told a Chines counterpart about that heroic effort of those Jawans the chines general asked where was your Anti Tank unit? our Fuji told sir it was in Nowshehra
Man stop praising them and point out thier faults they are not supper humans or only patriots….
Musharaf said in his speech there were 5000 students, we rescued 3300
where 1700 goes (they admit 73 were died there)
Others????? Army veporized them with thier Explosives or what?
They Hostage all pakistanis. Pakistan is made for these one million or two million peoples????
Who have no respect about Mosques and childrens and womens……
14072007
Sher Kohh(12:36:16) :
Mr. Mahmood,
you gave the example of Chowindah you know when one of our general proudly told a Chines counterpart about that heroic effort of those Jawans the chines general asked where was your Anti Tank unit? our Fuji told sir it was in Nowshehra
Man stop praising them and point out thier faults they are not supper humans or only patriots….
Musharaf said in his speech there were 5000 students, we rescued 3300
where 1700 goes (they admit 73 were died there)
Others????? Army veporized them with thier Explosives or what?
They Hostage all pakistanis. Pakistan is made for these one million or two million peoples????
Who have no respect about Mosques and childrens and women……
Sher Kohh, I’m the first to acknowledge the faults of the Pakistani Military but I don’t blame the rank and file Jawans but the leadership. It is the leadership, especially Musharraf who has taken a proud insitution and sullied its reputation among the public. We can’t deny the efforts and sacrifices made by Jawans in the last wars and their steadfastness in dealing with an enemy larger in number and better equipped. You are probably right that poor logistics forced our Jawans to undertake heroic self sacrificing measures to stop Indian tanks at Chawinda. The point is the soldiers were prepared to lay down their lives for the nation and they did without hesitation. Our Generals and Musharraf have grown fat off corruption in their civilian roles but I still don’t blame the Jawan who is likely a hardy, upright dignified Pakistani villager who is doing his job. I’ve already said that any loss of life in Pakistan is deplorable, including the senseless loss of life at the Lal Masjid- they are our fellow citizens and each one of their lives is as valuable as ours. Musharraf used the poor students for his own political gains. He could have shut down the Masjid months ago or simply surrounded the area to slowly force the management to its senses. Musharraf can’t understand this becuse he too is illegally occupying the seat of the President. I believe Musharraf shouuld be charged with treason to send a message to people that you can’t disrepect the laws and consitution of Pakistan.
14072007
Nadir(22:27:41) :
Brothers and sisters, 24 NaPak Army security personnel got killed and other 29 are wounded in Miranshah in a suicide attack this morning. These sort of attacks have become a routine since the “Operation Silence” had imposed on Lal Masjid. “Operation Silence” over the Innocent people has given birth to a much bigger “Operation Silence”, in which the Mujahideen will teach the NaPak Army, what does “Operation” mean? Insha-Allah, the day is not so far when Musharraf will be killed in an “Operation”. ALLAH(SWT) will take the best revenge of this brutality committed by the American dog Busharraf and his NaPak Army.
14072007
Mahmood(23:17:06) :
Why not work to remove Musharraf through peaceful means.
Those who are dying are all our brothers and sisters; both militants and the Army. By following the tactics of Musharraf- engaging in illegal operations and abusing the laws- we sink to the same level as Musharraf. Rallies and peaceul protests can do the job without harming our fellow citizens.
14072007
Mahmood(23:19:24) :
Why not work to remove Musharraf through peaceful means.
Those who are dying are all our brothers and sisters- our fellow citizens ; both militants and the Army personel. By following the tactics of Musharraf- engaging in illegal operations and abusing laws- we sink to the same level as Musharraf. Rallies and peaceul protests can do the job without harming our fellow citizens.
i can just say if this all were fair then it should be open for media to show the transparency . it was a brutal action by president. he tried to lead like hitler.
how can he say its islami jamhoriya pakistan ,if there is no right to protest by staunch believe muslims.
maulana and his fellows were teased against thier hard islamic views and remark for so long ,and make them ready and assure for this operation thats why they collected the gun for their defence , which is absolutely their right
all above they didnt misuse the women and kids ,otherwise they use them so suiside blast during operation to kill the army.
musharaf !!! what you will do when these innocent will ask the answer in qayamat in hashar ,
ik admi bhi bhoka soye tu uski zimaydari president ki hoti hay tum nay tu itnay baykasor mar daly ,for the sake of your satisfaction / ego and name .
15072007
Asif Baig(09:41:59) :
Shame Musharraf!!!!!!
president of pakistan is responsible for this blood shed. he is trying to resolve the issues by power. this matter should have solved by dialouges.
the silence operation is live example of the failure of the government. they should have use the brains.
15072007
Usman(11:44:17) :
Pervez Musfraf is not Muslim. He is no religion. He is not army person. He is not human being he a wild blood animal, he can gives her mother to USA free of cost. What I can say about him. All Pakistani HATE him. Allah Cursh him as soon as possible I pray.
musharaf has killed innocent people and removed their dead bodies too. he should be prepared now because now Allah tala must have planned something for him which would be very disastrous. inshallah.
15072007
Nadir(19:04:22) :
Brothers and sisters, here is a “shair” that perfectly suits this American dog who is ruling our country through gun-point.
AMRIKYON NE KUTTA PALA
GENERAL MUSHARRAF WARDI WALA
15072007
Mahmood(20:25:11) :
I’m not aware of all the sayings on the streets of Pakistan against Musharraf but I’ve heard my share of anti Musharaf comments. For years I’ve heard folks call Musharraf Bey sharraf . More important than this verbal rhetoric would be political agitation and protests to bring down the dictatorship and return Pakistan to a fucntioning democracy as envisioned by her founders. Rule of law and respect for our counsitution should be the mantra. I have a lot of faith in the new generation of Pakistanis who are sick of corruption and incompetence. I just want progress and stability in my beloved Pakistan. Political leades won’t matter when we have insitutions and a framework. Leaders will come and go but the system will remain- as in the West. It’s 2007 and Pakistan can be so much more than what it is- we all know we are better than the Arabs, Iranians or Afghanis in terms of intelligence and work ethic. It’s insulting that even the little Indians next door are progressing when the martial races of Pakistan are falling behind- Why should a venture capitalist in Europe or America invest in a dictatorship. I’m tired of being run by ignorant and illiterate military men who make our nation of 160 million look like a Banana Republic. Let’s show the world we are a principled nation by not calling for anyone’s death- rather work for democracy through mass action. When rule of law and the consitution is restored, criminals like Musharraf should be brought to trial and charged with treeason after due process. This would send a message to the world and also to future corrupt military Generals that the fate of all who violate the consitution will be the same- shame and ignomy.
16072007
SK(01:34:38) :
Why must everyone make this political? Yes it is mainly to be considered in a political concept, but look at it individually, the moulana Ghazi was so brain-washed, that his mother was dying in his lap, he still had a hard-heart.. you would think that at that moment, he will surrender. Toh aisa banda kisi aur bachay yah aurat ki parwah kyun aur kesay karega?? He just cares about his selfish reasons, which is that he wants to dictate the nation. He is DEMANDING control over the entire country, AND is blackmailing the nation with lives of children and women.
Bombing at night is due to not giving away your position to enemies, pagal logon, apni comment chornay say pehlay thora parh likh loh. Logon ki cheekhnay aur ronay ki away toh din ho ya raat, ayegi hee ayegi.
16072007
Mahmood(07:15:51) :
The Maulana was trying to exert control in an illegal manner- Musharraf continues to exercise control which he seized in an unconsitutional and illegal manner. What’s the difference?
16072007
Sheraz Sabri(20:45:35) :
This operation is dark lesson in the history of pakistan. We strickly protest this operataion as it may be solved by dialogues but unfortunately some dirty eggs do not like to solve this major issue by positive manner. We pray that ALLAH desroy these peoples as he destroy the peace of our country.
18072007
Mahmood(18:51:34) :
Let’s work peacefully to return Pakistan to a fucntionng democracy where there insitutions and rule of law. Let’s move to oust the illegal dictator who has seized control in an unconsitutional manner and who has made Pakistan an embarrassment to patriotic Pakistanis.
24072007
Sher Kohh(23:30:36) :
Dear Nadir
You are right it is a NaPak Army who only obey orders of
those non muslim type of generals to Destory and burn the Mosques and Madrasas with phosphoras bombs
and burn the Holy Quran and throw them in the gutter lines
“May Allah Destory them”
and Burn the helpless little girls mercilessly
They never obey the orders of Allah because they even dont know the orders of Almighty
Its not a Ilsamic army
for 50 Mujahideen They deploy 15000 miltary and non miltray Sherdil
Jawans
25072007
Mahmood(06:11:57) :
We all follow the tenets of Islam to our best understanding but it is not wise to let our emotions get the better of us. I am the first to say that the Lal Masjid affair was a fiasco brought about by a corrupt and illiterate Military General and his cabal of corrupt followers. However, it is unfair of accusing anyone in a Muslim nation, especially the common foot soldiers of our military of burning the holy Quran or throwing our holy book in the gutter. An act of such depravity simply isn’t possible. These type of comments do not serve any constructive purpose in the debate to return Pakistan to a civil society where there is rule of law and religious freedom as laid out in our constitution. My pint remains that a military dictator has no moral authority in the eyes of the people which is why everyone feels they are entitled to take the law into their own hands. If Musharraf can seize power illegally, ram road whatever he wants down the throats of Pakistanis and continue with a level of corruption greater than Nawaz or BB – surely no Pakistani will believe in rule of law. For this Musharraf must be tried for treason to send a message to all and sundry that our laws will be respected. Those who do not will pay a price.
26072007
Sher Kohh(00:05:19) :
Dear Mahmood
Please Tell me That i write some thing False…..
Didnt you see the burnd Qurans the Bodies and the soldiers Wearing Boots Standing in the Mosque and later found Burnt and Torn Quranic Pages in Gutter lines the bloody cloths burned pieces of bodies
Is that wise to follow an unislamic order ??????????????
If i order you to kill a person and you obey, on judgement day what you say to Allah ??? that i give you the order so you are innocent
He made you with brain and you are responsible of your doings you are not an animal that i force you to do that
On judgement day people say Satan force us to make sin and satan say i didnt they follow me ( both goes to Hell )
The Lal Masjid operation was necessary and justified after six months of patience and nine days of giving the armed fanatics inside chances to surrender. The deaths and the destruction that followed are the responsibility of the Lal Masjid Brigade, who even refused to listen to the Imam-e-Kaaba.
Musharraf made a mistake in suspending the CJ, he made the right decision to destroy the Lal Masjid Brigade.
26072007
Waqas Huqqani(10:22:44) :
Toataly wrong decision, attaking on Lal Masjid. Shame for us , in a muslim Country mulsim Ministers muslim army killing muslim even in Masjid , This one did Sadam Husain in past and now doing Musharraf for creating an atmosphere to invite other cuntries in pakistan proof (as we see and listen that america say we can attack any doubt spot in pakistan any time to finish terror). Now we have ( our government) proof that there are terrorsit in masjads and madrasas and people go in masjids to practice five time terror, sorry to say but so is the reality becaz what present governament did, lal masjid issue is an international issue becaz pakistani governament has attached this one with talliban and talliban are selfly created most wnated terrorist in the world. Musharraf did so to make happy Europ and America, to prevet his own illegel Government ( by showing himself Herro aainst terror in pakistan) to delay the allections…. In 1992 in india hidu attacked on Babri masjid and shahied it and we see how did protest all muslim in india, and now more worst is going in pakistan and we all are silent cllaping and happy saying Musharraf did good. No he did totaly wrong and distroy the image of pakistan.I ask from those who are saying that musharraf did good then answer me what did pakistan achive from lal majid oppration? in next i will told you what did pakistan loos in this opperation?
29072007
saeed(16:58:15) :
it was not in the favour of islam and muslims. the muslim army Killed the muslim students for what ? they were not demanding any thing unislamic are anything against Pakistan, becouse pakistan was made for muslims to live according the islamic ways of life. their way of demand may be incorrect but the funnishment was just too much.
31072007
Mulvi Shafakut Ali(23:26:18) :
What the fuck uses playing at have some respect its a place of worthship the house of allah or you have forgot that. what did raid on lal mosque achieve the dead of 20 innocent muslims. This all is the agenda of the west
31072007
Mulvi Shafakut Ali(23:30:59) :
What the fuck uses playing at, have some respect its a place of worthship the house of allah or you have forgot that. what did raid on the lal mosque achieve the death of 20 innocent muslims. This all is the agenda of the agenda of the west
May Allah be with you
1082007
Mahmood(00:49:40) :
We are all Muslims and we all respect places of worship, mosques or otherwise. It is a fundamental premise of our faith. Having said that, what does a civil society do when members of the mosque take the law into their own hands. If they feel so stronlgy about imposing Islamic laws in the land, why not work legally within the system to push for laws and action against acts which are felt to be unislamic. My main point of contention is that we need to build a civil society run by laws and our constitution. I know what most Western newspapers are saying. They believe strongly that Musharraf’s illegal occupation of the presidency and abrogation of laws creates lawlessness and insecurity. People see that Musharraf can do as his wish with no regard for the laws, so why should the Lal Masjid folks follow any laws?
I believe that all Pakistanis need to follow our laws and respect our consitution. We are not some Afghanistan- our people are not Arabs, Persians, Turks or Afghanis- we are Pakistanis and as such we should hold ourselves to higher accountability by establishing rule of law. In short both Musharraf and the Lal Masjid folks are law breakers- you decide who is the bigger law breaker- maybe Musharraf becasue he has set the whole thing in motion. By the way I still believe the Lal Masjid affair was initially orchestrated by Musharraf himself.
9082007
saima ashraf(16:25:16) :
it is just as clear as crystal everyone has its own views but being a muslim………….is it rite to do all ds stuff with our religious places n the ppl who r here to tell us our norms as a muslim……its just a drama to kill the ppl who wanna make pak a fullfledge muslim state not a so called one…….n dats all..its totally an unfair game
jo log musharraf ko support karte hai wo log sacche musalman nahi hai apne aap ko pehchano musalmaano
31082007
Adarsh(22:54:32) :
Its a shame hw some Muslim ediots supports these terrorits……..terrorists r terrorists b it men or women !!
Rajiv Gandhi was assasinated by ladies………( terrorists L.T.T.E. )
Im a Hindu bt can say yes L.T.T.E. is a terrorist org.
bt for some Muslims its so hard 2 realize the fact………..these so called Muslims r a menace 2 the society………….wake up before they started killing u !!
3 cheers for Musharraf for fucking the asses of these bastards !!!!!!!
1092007
Adarsh Choudhury(00:18:44) :
lets make this world a better place………………..this is not 7th century its 21st century!!! grow up guys………..
6112007
Sher Koh(21:07:29) :
So Dear Mehmood,
What you say now about the peacefull means to remove Mush
Good Content – [url=http://www.intersponse.net]website traffic[/url] Will recommend. Website Traffic Visit us as well
7052008
marry(15:52:58) :
I HATE ALL THOSE PEOPLE WHO WERE INVOLVE IN THIS OPERATION.I WILL SEE THEM ON THE DAY OF JUDGEMENT.THIS OPERATION IS OCCURED ON BEHALF
OF AMERICA IS IT OUR FRIEND? IT COULD BE OUR FRIEND ANY TIME? NEVER NEVER .WHY DO U AGREE WITH PRESIDENT BUSH(STUPID).
14072008
saqib rauf(09:24:10) :
Lal masjid people lost their lives but they keep up the pride of islam. They wanted only islam and our govt tried to insult them. Their insult was insult of islam. So they lost their lives but keep the pride of islam up.
Thanks a lot to Lal masjid.
This is totally wrong information they were having any negative agenda against common man or liberal people. They were having a massage of peace for all world but not for protitutes and cruel people
17042009
BAKHMIR KHAN(15:40:08) :
yeh sub kam musharaf gandu nay kia ha,,,,or masoom bacho ka qatal e aam kia ha…..manay khud lal masjid may 3 days guzaray thay..or mjhy nhi lgta k yeh sub asla un k pass pehlay say mojoud tha.. balkay yeh sab kuch media or america ko dikhanay k liay aik drama tha..or pakistani qoum ko bewaqoof banana tha…..
17042009
qasim(22:59:47) :
they just make a drama amrica he don’t like islam even muslims .i pray one day in pakistan every body hate amrica . me i prayu for all muslims
All the issue of Lal masjid is Topi Drama by Musharaf.
Do you really think it is ? People do say, but these students are trying to make Pakistan like Taliban. I mean according to me Musharraf has nothing to do with it. He has just ordered the attack on the Mosque, which is Great !
As the drama of lal masjid is on its peak, the reluctance of Pakistan army and other para malitary forces to launch a full fledge operation in Lal Masjid, I doubt that there might some high figures from AQ may be hidden in this mosque, as Maulana abdul aziz was having some direct links to these people.
Who is hidden inside?? except for the Gazi Rasheed and his body gaurds?????
All these militants deserve a military action like this sooner than later. I am glad Musharraf decided to do this. All these extremist fanatics who think they are bigger than the law deserve this. I hope our media does not paint a romantic /filmi pic of women militants just ‘cuz they are women.. thay all deserve this. It needs to send a message to any Mullah doing terrorism in name of Islam!!
And for those skeptics out their.. appreciate what Musharraf is trying to do…we need this or get ready for Pakistan to become another Afghanistan
just I want to say they are not Muslim it is tourism by the name of Islam I want to say one word it is that if I was president of Pakistan I was to cut maulana aziz and Abdul Rashid hade I mean I would kill them if I was president I am wait president parwez Musharaf Saab he is the great man in the pakistan even world God bless him inshalah even you can publish my words with all I am not afraid no one Except Allah just finish the tourisms Great Musharaf Pakistan Zenda Bad
It’s about time that the government closed down the Lal Masjid and similar centres which give a bad name to both Islam and Pakistan. I am disgusted that the Musharraf government waited so long to act. From the beginning they could have created a cordon around the Mosque to isolate and starve the group until they came to their senses. I believe that the Lal Masjid drama was kept alive by Musharraf for a while because it serves his interests. That is to say he wants to show the world that if not for the dictatorship of Musharraf, Pakistan would head towards Taliban style anarchy. This is simply untrue because most Pakistanis are fed up with these silly extremists who are taking the law into their own hands. The problem is that the current President also took the law into his own hands when he dismissed the civilian Prime Minister and made himself President and Chief. Musharraf too has no authority and perhaps that’s why there is so much lawlessness throughout the country. Monkey see and monkey do. If the army chief can break the consitution and flout laws why shouldn’t everyone else. We need rule of law for all which is why I would vote for the suspended Chief Justice if he ever runs for office!
I am in doubt that we are really muslims? To get some benefit in form of Aids from foreign countries, we are ready to kill each other. What is all behind this issue is just politics. And they are killing the innocent peoples. I have a question to pakistan government and other people involved in this operation that they are hitting mosque ( the Home of Allah). It is shame for all of us (muslims).
hate army
Pakistan politics are controlled by army generals, they are all sold out to America, So they can kill every Innocent Muslim in pakistan by declaring as AQ terriest, if they killing Innocent Muslim in Pakistan, one day a big Earth Quake will be destroyed the Islambad, and other area’s where, these army General living and enjoy there life and killing the innocent people in pakistan and got Money from America and Briton. One day Allah will Kepture from there head and dropped on floor. Allah helps the innocent Muslim os Pakistan and the rest of world. and save them from Army General who are big Terroriest in this world
This is a fight between understanding ISLAM. (Religion). Army generals and other modern MUSLIMS are influenced by Europeans culture and they studied all their life only secularism and know nothing about ISLAM. May ALLAH swt help all of us to understand ISLAM and practice it. INSHAHALLAH a day will come when truth separates from the lie. Be a slave of ALLAH, save your world and hereafter.
[...] This Pakistani blog is interesting in its own right if you like to get the perspective of people who actually live in an area. But I was particularly interested in the comments on this post here. [...]
yaa kaam musharaf gandu ni aacha nahe keya ha
sirf itna clear hona chaiye k ager islam ko phailana hay to piyar mohabat say phailao or ager sheriat ka nifaz kerna hay to sheriat main koi piyar mohabat or nermi nai hay. or Lal Masjid walay sheriat ka nifaz chahtay thay..woh bilkul theek thay theek hain or ham log ghalat hain jo unhain ghalat keh rahay hain..asal main ham log khud to kuch ker nai saktay or jo kernay lagay usay bura bhala kehtay hain..
hi friends
it is a great plot being played against pakistan and the people of Pakistan. Who are mulvies, i think musharaf can better answer this question. In short army and molvies are doing nothing but facilitating the ways to handover pakistan completely to America.
isn’t it.
The actions taken by Lal Masjid and adjacent school organisors like picking up of Chinese prostitutes, burning of Video casettes or any other similar adventures are highly condemned. In the presence of country’s laws and concerned authorities, no one can atke the law in the hands.
Having said that, the present level of issue seems as if intentially created by General Pervez Musharaf and his team. He is trying to support his utmost to the disgraced extremists group leaders – the US President Bush and ousted UK Prime Minister Tony Blair. Both Western leaders have lost their support in their own people. I can’t understand that why still Pervez Musharaf is still batting on the lost horse. And not only that but also puting his own country on very dangerous stage and whole nation in continous torture.
Where was the govt writ before today. Why the parents of the children in mosque are not allowed to vist their children and get them back. Why today members of parliament were arrested today ? Why the parliamentarians when allowed to visit today the mosque, heavy fire started by the govt. forces ? Why until now those children who many days before left the mosque are now still in jail ? Why electricity, gas, water are disconnected for the residents of the area in miles and miles. Because the govt has fear that public will supor them ? How the heavy fire is open on the innocent children in mosque ? Who will give the answers to that. Shame on the present rulers
To me Pakistan means so much more than any leader – it’s time for Musharraf to go. He has shown himself to be an opportunist and incompetent. The poor kids in the Lal Masjid are still our people- good or bad. Months ago the government should have acted to close off the area around the school and encourage the students inside to leave. He kept the drama going on for so long for political mileage. He wants to show everyone in the West” Hey if not for me, look what will happen to this country”.If not for the abduction of the Chinese, he probably would have left the Lal Masjid alone for longer. China remains Pakistan’s only true friend and even an uneducated dictator like Musharraf realized that the Chinese could not be offended. It’s disgusting that he views Pakistani lives so cheaply. The death of even one Pakistani student is too a price to pay for Musharraf’s incompetence. With all of the aid money the West is providing to fight terrorism cannot the Army spend more on proper schools and insitutions for our kids. It’s wasted on corrupt generals and their pet projects. If Musharraf has any shame he should step down before he damages the nation more.
this should be done earlier
how cheap the ghazi brothers .they are taking advantage of small boys and girls
…
The situation is very sensitive and critical between Government and jameha Hifza.
who is rite and who is wrong this is another matter but why they trapped innocent lives in that cage.
So sad situation for muslims.
now we can easily imagine that the day of Judment is not so far.
but this time the Government is helpless infact not helpless they can do bitter operation they have power but they cant just becoz of innocent guys and women who are inside jamieha.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
as a muslim
.
.
we have to pray for all ppl who r inside and in great trouble……
ALLAH un ko apne hifzo Amaan main rakhey Amin…..
It is important to find out that how and where are these so called students in Lal Musjid are getting their arms and ammounitions, who is funding their efforts.
Go Musharaf go, clean this mess up, these; so called students are not loyal to the country of Pakistan, you know which country are their leaders are loyal to and are funded. Do not hazitate, level the ground, we can build another Mosque right away at the same spot.
Musharaf you have support, its just most of the your supporters are honarable and piece loving people and do not want to take time to defend your efforts.
Go Musharaf GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
All of the supporters of these Students / Mullahs in Lal Musjid, I have one simple questions. “Where did these guys get Arms from”. Try to find the answer to this questions and you will understand what is going on and who is behind this. This is not the end of it, I guarantee you we will see more.
Saima Gul
Kick their butts and put them all away for a long period of time. They do not deserve to be a Pakistani. Shame on all of us of not taking care of these people earlier. Send them back where they all came from.
If Pres Musharaf have some proof regarding the use of lal masjid for terriorism, he must show it on media, before any major operation. this will avoid further policicall issue violance in country
If Pres Musharaf have some proof regarding the use of lal masjid for terriorism, he must show it on media, before any major operation. this will avoid further policicall issue violance in country
AHA
Sab se Pehle Islam
Not
Sub se Pehle Pakistan
Any way Our GREAT PAK ISLAMIC ARMY once again Concoring their own country
caz they ONY can This type of shit
PAkistan Se Zinda Bhag
IN SITUATION LIKE THIS TRUST ME I WILL NEVER ATTACK A MOSQUE ATLEAST, UNLESS I AM A PUPPET TO A FOREIGN POWER. I WILL LET ALL OF THEM IN THE MOSQUE VICINITY GO FREE UNTILL THE TIME I CATCH EXACTLY THE PERSON IF I HAVE TO WITHOUT ANY BLOOD SHED AND BIG SHOW LIKE THIS. A NON BELIEVER IS FREE THIS WORLD IS JANNAT FOR HIM AND WE PAKISTAN MUSLIMS ARE NOT TAKING PRIDE IN OUR KALIMAH AND THE SUNNAT TARIQA AND TRYING TO FOLLOW THE WEST.
THIS PERVEZ IS A WARNER AZAB OF ALLAH FOR US TO CHANGE OUR LIVES ACCORDING TO ISLAM.
SOME PEOPLE DIE IN BED AND SOME ON THE ROAD EVENTUALLY EVERYONE DIES SO LET US BE GOOD MUSLIMS AND BE EXAMPLERY MUSLIMS AND DIE WITH KALIMAH. EVEN FOR PERVEZ MUSHARAF TO MAKE HIM A TRUE MUSLIM AND LEADER. FOR THAT WE HAVE TO CHANGE OURSELVES FIRST. ALLAH SENDS HIS AZAAB IN DIFFERENT FORMS TO CORRECT US IN THIS WORLD INSTEAD OF PUTTING US IN THE FIRE OF HELL, “WHICH SURELY WOULD NOT GIVE ANY BENEFIT TO ALLAH TABARAK WATALLAH”.
SO LET US TURN TO ALLAH AND FOLLOW THE SUNNAT TARIQA, AND STOP INTERNAL PROBLEMS IN THE COUNTRY, ALLAH WISHES OUR LIFE AND DEATH WILL BE SUCCESSFUL.
LET US MAKE DUA TO ALLAH TABARAK WATALLAH, WITH OUR FIVE TIME CORRECT SALLAH.
HE SURELY IS MOST MERCIFUL.
AMEEN.
I hope the good people of Pakistan defeat these Taliban types, inshalla…
absurd thought -
God of the Universe says
let extremists rule
they will drag your country
back to seventh century
.
is it possible that such a big war preparation took place in a mosque in the middle of islamabad in the presence of an intelligience organization like ISI who has played a major role in defeating U S S R ?
We r Muslims Not Terrorist …Gr8 Job Musharaf
Khallas….!!!
hmmm interesting comments…..ok what i think is that those mulla’s goals are genuine…infact every one wants islamic law in this country…but the procedure to achieve those goals very not lawfull….they should be trying to deliever their messege to everyone PEACEFULLY…..i think that was the right procedure of spreading islam….
“REMEMBER …. IF WE WANT THIS COUNTRY TO MOVE IN RIGHT DIRECTION…..WE SHOULD MAKE SURE …. THAT EVERYONE OBEY THE LAW”
Look at how low and shameless the Pakistani govt has proved themselves as… Killing alims, alimas, hafiz n hafizas, the leaders of the Muslims tomorrow and the strong hold of the Muslim Ummah, all because some haram prostitutes declared that their rights have been violated – or maybe the Pakistani govt sees it as their own ‘duty’ to honour these filthy women by bringing them justice, from the restrictions Shariah, OUR Belief, and OUR Lord places on them??
They’ve had months to close down them brothels, massage parlours, and music shops.
The students of Laal Masjid who yes, have alhamdulila decided to take the Islamic Law into their own more worthy hands, because the government has disregarded it for so long. But they didn’t listen, didn’t take heed, so what do they expect?
You might say both are in the wrong, but do u know that 325 students have been shaheed early morning today?! And no, even though imam ghazi has asked and requested, the Great Muslim Army has prevented any journalists from entering and seeing the damage. And so, unless u saw the broadcast in the morning with the interview with imam ghazi, u wont hear about that again. The utter shame and disgrace!
All due respect to the army and their supposed heroism, but if they die fighting against those who attempted to uphold the deen and the laws of Allah, can you imagine the state they will be raised up on on the day of qiyamah?
May Allah give martyrdom or victory to His true servants, in both cases, they’re successful. And to quote a female student of laal masjid, ‘we’ve worn our kaffans, and we’re ready’ and as imam ghazi said yesterday, ‘the students say we have done nothing wrong, and say they will never bow down before firawn’. That’s the strength this ummah needs.
I do not support extremisim, but when these people were fighting against Russia, they were world’s heroes and now, all of us are against them. If you use some one for a porpuse and then turn against him then he would be extremist against you.
My personal belief is that in future any muslim who will ask for an islamic society will be treated like a militant or extremist. So muslims must prepare to accept the fate of shameful western culture or face the hard actions from their own guards.
we hate musharraf because he is doing this drama just to keep hidden the case of chief justice as well as APC and may be he will do some more behind this. musharraf will also do like this when he needs and tomorrow he will start fight against any pakistani area. ALLAH give him Hedayat if there is no Hedayat for him then ALLAH funishe him very soon.
Maulana Abdur Rasheed Ghazi is a soldier of Islam and fighting in the way of Allah. I ask the people here in this forum, what’s wrong if the Lal Masjid people struggling for Allah’s (SWT) rule in this country? With what aim we got freedom in 1947? Our slogan was, “Pakistan ka matlab kia, La Illaha Ill-Allah”. what does this mean? This means that there should be a place where Muslims could live their lives according to their religion. It was not possible living with India, so our demand was justified by the famous slogan mentioned above. Then after the independence, we forgot our cause of separation from India. Our ancestors sacrificed their lives for their dreams of an Islamic state. Is this an Islamic state? What is the sin that is not done in this so-callad “Mumlikat-e-Khudadad”? There are Vine shops in this country, porn CD/DVD shops in this country, prostitution is a common practice in this country, half naked women on the huge billboards/banners in this country, murderers are rulers in our country, one who has power can do whatever he wants and there is no law for him……..These are countless. So my fellow Muslim Brothers and sisters, only SHARIAH LAW can protect us from these sins. It is due to our sin that Allah has cursed us with the present corrupt rulers. Do you see what they are doing with the Lal Masjid Mujahideen(may Allah bless them all), their crime is that they are struggling for Allah’s law. Injustice in our country could only be ended by Allah’s rule. O! My fellow Muslim brothers and sisters, I request you to please analyze the current situation and think what is going on. Don’t believe just what the rulers say, use your mind also. if the government is true in all its claims, then why it is not allowing the media to go inside th “Lal Masjid”? Think upon it. It is all occuring because they see their end and end of their corruption in Allah’s law. Thank You.
Maulana Abdur Rasheed Ghazi is not a soldier of Islam,he is a terrorist,a criminal and he should be shot and hang his body in Islamabad.
Nadir I don’t think matters are as black and white as you present. I don’t support the government because it too is illegal and unconstitutional. Musharraf is the biggest embarrassment for Pakistan because he makes our country look like a Banana Republic ruled by the military. He comes across as an illiterate and uneducated man in the West – and not only because he is so poor in spooken English. He used the Lal Masjid folks for his own purposes and now he wants to pull the plug. It’s a shame that it has come to this.I want Pakistan to get back to a functioning democracy where there is rule of law for all. However the folks in the Lal Masjid were clearly taking the law into their own hands. Initially they were encouraged by Musharraf so he could show the world what he was up against but then after the incident with the Chinese he was forced to stop them. Musharraf is a criminal becasue he cares so little about Pakistan and her people. As for all the vice in Pakistan -Can we not fight against the injustices in Pakistan through peaceful means. By all means demonstrate outside stores where you feel porno is being sold or stop patronizing hotels where you believe there is prositution or boycotting restaurants where the owners are serving alcohol and drugs. Pakistanis are not Arabs or Afghanis or Iranians- despite our leaders the common people have a tradition of working for things in a civilized way through discussion and dialogue
These maulvis have no purpose left in life but to brainwash people and to try to take over the world. GET REAL. Islam is not about just spreading Islam. Its more about creating a balance in life, understanding life, and making the most of what we have in this world. These people have turned into maniacs, psychos with a lost cause.
Why can they not work on making themselves better “Muslim” first, before they go about and try to take an entire nation under their control? And even if they are given control, what is the guarantee that even under Shariah law these rulers will not have personal interests conflicting with Shariah rule?
As far as Musharaff is concerned, regardless of his political stance, what matters is that right now he is on the verge of cleaning out a cancerous cell, and this is important before it spreads in the entirety.
Yeh khud hee gunehgar hain joh masoom jaanon koh kabzay mein rakhay huay hain, aur dhamkaa rahay hain. Upar say kehtay hain kay government masoom jaanain ley rahi hay. Yeh naubat hee nahi aati agar inki be-tuqi farmayeshein naa hoteen…
ALLAH TALLAH IN MAULVION KOH AQAL DEIN. AMEEN.
I also agree with Mahmood and m waqar.
Nadir, a real soldier of Islam would be against what is happening. Did anyone ever think that a holy and beautiful place as a masjid (House of ALLAH SWT) would ever be ground for war? La haula wala quwat. A real soldier of Islam would promote peace and just put and end to chaos. These are not soldiers but enemies of Islam, they just do not realize that. They are creating barriers within Islam and breaking it apart.
I request that you think of it for a second, just apart from what everyone argues, just use your brain. Think hard, apart from what Islam “tells” us it is about. Think for yourself, what is Islam about. QUESTION IT!!! QUESTION and DOUBT ISLAMIC principles and you will find the REAL ISLAM! Look inside your heart, not at what others tell you and brainwash you. If this was to make things better, they would have been better. But for past few years things have been getting worse and worse and worse. Musalman mooh dikhanay layak nahi rahay. Khud hee dekho khud hee socho.
Assalam o ALaikum
As Mufti Taqi Saheb db said, the demands and motives were praiseworthy, however the tactic were not good.
Those who say that its a good thing musharraf is doing so, I ask in light of humane morality,
Is prostitution good? Is the filth of Fahsh (explicit) movies good? Is destruction of mosque good? Why didnt the govt do their responsibility even after complaints were given to the “law of land”
and in this particular case, is it any beneficial to do military action while Mr. Ghazi etc were willing to cooperate only if a safe passage is given…
Finally, its a shame that the media ploy is as vibrant in Pakistan as it is in US or any western country. Read this http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/ummat_news-09072007-30.gif
The question is, which actions do we see more islamic? Shahadat in Islam or Liying to your children.. that I think will explain our true motives. Dont get me wrong, but a masjid is being torn to pieces.. I will not care of the context but to save the house of Allah alone be willing to say out loud to stop this atrocity!
Wassalam
if some says that molana is spreading islam but i think and most of them agree with me that it is totally wrong way of spreading islam
how can it spread in this way?
and jehad does’nt mean to kill people………..
and i think v r own responsible of making our image bad around the globe by doing all these whether it is done by Molana or Musharaf……………………….
and the escape of the honour of the Mosque in wearing BURQA is vvvv shame full 4 all muslims…………
if they want to surrender then should be just like a men not by weraing BURQA …………
by doing this he leave not agood example for reamining ones inside the mosque………………….
Dear All,
Its not a points scoring game, we all should think about the root cause of all the unrest in our country and around the muslim world. The only solution to these issues is chosing the right path of islam. We should not just waste our time by blaming Musharraf or Moulana Brothers. We must have to think about the negative consequences and to prepare our self to combat with the repercusions. Everyone has the right of expression but we should look and study the circumstances. Always be positive.
We are giving opportunity to our so-called WELL WISHERS to laugh on us and to divide us as much as they can. We’re really in trouble and going thru a very very tough time of our history. Its not only the issue of Lal Masjid, Aunti Shamim, Library or Massage centres. But its an issue and problem of our country, province, city and our home. NAd I’m sure nobody will want to see their home like that.
So to say the mosque is being attacked. How conveniently the world is getting the impression that the people inside are traitors, culprits, terrorists. What has not surfaced is the fact that the two leaders that started this coo are ISI agents acting as Mr. Musharaf puppets. Their ultimate goal; eliminate all the madrasas in Islamabad, fill hated among the people for din and create a police state where no sect will be able to practice their beliefs openly. Shame on such people, one day you will face Allah and he will then decide what your ultimate fate will be.
A shameful attempt to deceive the West and USA…! Human rights organizations must take notice. A military dictator should not be let to keep on at the cost of lives of innocent citizens. Blood of Ladies and children is being used to fuel the illegitimate Musharraf regime. Can USA and West be inspired by this drama which has many flaws if we have a closer look at it? Civil administration and mosque administration touched a peaceful solution many times but always sabotaged by the military regime. “Shoot at sight” orders for media personnel at the time of final operation tells that military regime wants to hid the facts from pubic and international media.
According to my point of view, all the political parties that are in exile and in Pakistan are united and behind this. They are using the extremists to breakdown Musharaf’s leadership. These extremists and the ignorant burden of Pakistani society should be warned to get back on normal track, if not, there’s no other solution than getting them all together and burning them all!
Aaj K iss Wakia per Mujay Bohat e
dukh k saath kehna per raha hay k Govt nay operation ker diya or Govt k daway jotay niklay k hum waha per bayguna auraton or Bachon ko bachana chatay hain. Laykin esa nai huwa Q k baz kowatain masliat cha ti e nai thi. may yaha yeh nai kehna chata k Lal Masjid walay teek thay ya unhoon nay acha kia. agar govt chati tho wo yeh masla hal kr sakti thi or govt k haath may tha k wo inn logon ko bcha sakti thi magar govt ki america nawaz policy or Hadarmi ki waja say itni logon ki janay gawai. Allah in sub ko Janat ul Firdos may jaga dey Aamin. Or agar govt un ko safe passege b deh dehti tho mera nai kiyal ko wo govt ki nazro say door hotay. Govt un logo ko badh may b arrest kr sakti thi or hamari agencies ko tho her eik cheez ki kabar hoti hay. Or agar govt ka yeh mokaf a k yeh log mulk k liyeh khatra hain tho mera kiyal k iss waqat Govt may jitnay b hukumran hain wo apnay gareban may jank kr dekhy k kia wo mulk k liyeh katra nai or un per bayguna logo k katal k mukadimat b hain or sub sy baray tho hamray mulk k liyeh katra tho iss waqat hamaray Hukumran hain.
Army took right step….which was very necessary to resolve this influence against the Muslims enemy….
At last, Maulana Abdur Rasheed Ghazi and other Mujahideen have been martyred. May Allah be pleased with them all and let them enter the Paradise for their Shahada. Maulana Ghazi spoke for truth and got perished for it. If anyone analyzes what he said to the media at different times regarding the current crisis, he will found no contradiction in his talks, and it is a fake allegation by the Govt. that he changes his statements continuously. Maulana Ghazi and his elder brother were deceived by the Govt. who did not negotiated sincerely with these brothers. Yesterday, when our respected clerics were trying to resolve this situation through peaceful means and there had been prepared a draft for it and Maulana Ghazi and the ministers with the help of clerics were very near of the peaceful resolution, musharraf interrupted and amended in that draft which ended all these negotiations. He always wants to deal with any situation through gun-point. He likes bloodshed and wants to ruin our country through his dictatorship. Even media personnel are restricted to practice their duties honestly.
in the end I will request people here to make a Dua’a for these Shaheed Mujahideen, and also to get rid of Mr. President.
I too am disappointed to see the unecessary loss of life in the Lal Masjid debacle. It is an embarrassment for Pakistan and shows the incompetence of Musharraf and his dictatorship. This whole matter could have been settled long ago through peaceful means. It’s all a political drama and the poor students have been manipulated by the government and the Mullahs. I’ve said this before : the people in the Lal Masjid are our fellow Pakistanis- they were duped by both the military and the Mosque leaders. We need to create real educational opportunities for our fellow citizens. As for these Maddrasahs I’m sorry there is no role for any type of vigilante actions. Just because Musharraf disrespects the laws of Pakistan doesn’t mean other Pakistanis have the right to take the law into their own hands. Let’s learn to fight for our beliefs through constitutional and legal means. We might just strengthen our institutions and create a civil society in the process- the progressive social democratic Islamic state envisioned by Iqbal!
salam
now READ NEWS CAREFULLY
OPERATION SILENCE STARTED on 4:40 AM 10 july 2007
LALMASJID BREAKFAST: BOMBS n BLOODSHED
MOLANA AR GHAZI, HIS MOTHER n 700 ISLAMIC MILITANTS KILLED
AMERICA APPRECIATES MUSJARRAF ON WAR AGAINST EXTREMISM
MUSHARRAF CHANGED THE DRAFT: M RAFI USMANI
OPERATION SILENCE CONTINUES AT NIGHT
15 SECURITYMEN KILLED n HUNDREDS WOUNDED
DEATHS ARE NOT BEING SHOWN TO MEDIA BCOZ ARMY KILLED WOMEN n CHILDREN INSIDE
NO INJURED PEOPLE FROM RED MOSQUE ADMITTED IN HOSPITALS: PAKISTAN MEDIA
MORE THAN 140 BOMBS USED IN COMBAT
SHUJAT, DURANI, EJAZULHAQ n TARIQAZEEM DISAPPOINTED FROM DIALOGUES
VERY DISAPPOINTMENT FROM PAKISTAN PEOPLE EXCEPT BENAZIR BHUTTO
X ARMY CHEIF MIRZA ASLAM BAIG CONDEMNS MUSHARRAF ACTION
GOVT SAYS THERE ARE FORIGNERS INSIDE: WHY GOVT TAKE U TURN?
WE HAVENOT KILLED, RAPED n ANY OTHER CRIME SO WHY WE ARE BEING PUNISHED? THIS COUNTRY WILL BE A MUSLIM STATE ONE DAY AMIN: LAST TALK OF MOLANA ABDUL RASHID GHAZI (shaheed?) WITH MEDIA
AFTER EFFECTS?
thanks
cooolstar
MUSHARRAF AND ARMY KILLED WOMEN AND CHILDREN IN OPERATION SILENCE AT LAL MASJID RED MOSQUE ISLAMABAD PAKISTAN.
THEY DID NOT ALLOW ANY MEDIA MAN TO KNOW WHAT WAS THEY DOING THERE.
cooolstar
Dear Fellow Pakistanis, Before everyone starts beating the “ISLAMIC DRUM” and portraying as the best Muslims hence declaring all others, “moderates”, KAFIRS, why don’t you take a little test of your own Islamic knowledge. The question is in our society what percentage approves of a marriage with an “ahle-kitab”? Answer this to yourself, I would guess your answer would range from 70% to a 100%. Now please answer that of those people that accept such a marriage, how many will be willing to eat a regular McDonald’s beef burger in the West (since such a burger is said to be haram)? I would guess the answer to range in atleast 60% to 80% of those who accept the ahle-kitab marriage. Now are you guys ready for THE shock of your life, go to any library / mosque and pick at least 5 Qurans, read Sura Al-Maeda Ayat 5, here is a link to online translation http://www.usc.edu/dept/MSA/quran/005.qmt.html
The Quran clearly states that both the food and women (in marriage) of ahle-kitab are halal now think of it this way, why did our Islamic “SCHOLARS” only made the food haram and women halal (of ahle-kitab). Can it be to satisfy the greater animal urge that women of ahle-kitab were made halal and food (the lesser of urge under normal circumstances) made haram. Listening to what Allah has said in Quran, either they should both be halal or both be haram, there is no room for exclusion or extortion of Al-Maeda no. 5 as its logic requires no tafseer. The words used are women, food, halal, haram, all these words are extremely common in Quran thus no linguistic problem can be there either. My intent is to show you the extent hypo-criticism in our society.
My dear brothers and sisters in Islam, we have a book that was sent to us from Allah, please take it out of the covers and start reading it and you would come to know that you do not need MAULANA ABDUL RASHEED GHAZI to teach you Islam. Islam teaches patience and not torching of government buildings and vehicles. If any one of you can find an instance where a house of a non-Muslim was burnt EVER in the times of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), the answer will be NO.
Now at the end let me give you all a little time-line of how we Pakistanis got to the shameful occurring of the last week. In 1977, Prime Minister ZA Bhutto, took out the genie of radicalism (please do not mix islam with radicalism and terrorism by calling it Islamic radicalism, there is no such thing) by politicizing religion and drawing a clear line through our already divided society by banning alcohol, oh by the way wasn’t Bhutto a ‘fish’ when it came to drinking himself? Then came the doomed era of Zia-ul-Haq (the reason I do not write General is that 99% of our Army is same people as you and me and only 1% are the real problem the people on top). Zia used religion for his own vested interests and for the interests of everyone else. The genie grew. Then came Ms. Bhutto, who claims to be the biggest liberal of Pakistan but forgets that it was during her time that Taliban were created under the due supervision of Mr. Nasir Ullah Babar and if she tries to tell her that Taliban were created by ISI, please ask her why did she not resign, if she was so powerless? As for Nawaz Sharif and other Mulla lot, we all know the foundries and the diesel permits and all. Then came Mr. Musharaf, he is not much different than others either however the only problem is that yesterday he tried to go after the genie that has been fed and blown out of proportion since 1977. Let us all pray for ALL those who died and lets also pray that our shameful leaders on both sides of the divide get some fear of Allah (the one mentioned in Quran). Allah Hafiz.
salam
aap kisi ha ?
i think gen. musharaf did what he must did a long time before .
we want peace
we want a country without terror and violence
we want a country without taliban
i like to tell it is the time we cut the usa and saudi arabi hands and support of taliban
INA LILLAH HAY WA INA ILLAIHAY RAJAOON. ALLAH molana gazi rasheed (shaheed) ko is ajar to zarror day ga lakin hamaray liya ya nasihat hay kay un logon nay kis liya ya sab qurbaniyan dee sirf islam ko mulak main phalanay kay liya. lakin hum log sirf batain he kar saktay hain bus or kuch nah. kya wo log galat kar rahay thay go kuch islamabad main chinesse massage center main ho raha tha lakin afsson hay hamain apnay app per. or hadis ka mahfoom hay kay jab log naiki ka hukam danay or burai say rokna chor dain gay to bohot buray hukmran tum per ban jain gay. ( Tirmizi Shareef ) . or ab ap khud he dakh lain jo kuch ho raha hay. Afssos hay is bat per. ap ya socain kay GHAZI ABUL RASHEED SHAHEED KAY nam kay shuru main gazi or end per shaheed a gaya. wah gazi abdul rasheed shaheed g ap or ap kay sathiyon per sallam.
A good citizen of world thinks regardless of religion, race and color. If you can’t give positive and liberal point of view, don’t write down extremism supporting bullshit comments. We needed leader like Musharaf long time before. Enough of Arab influence on Pakistani culture, it has to end up! Our society needs broad minded people judging people not with their religions, colors and nationalities but as a person. Islam is not as complicated as these Mulla guys have made in Pakistan.
I agree that Islam is not a complicated religion and that some of our Mullahs are misguided. However the last thing we need is an illiterate and incompetent leader like Musharraf who stumbles from one problem to the next. It’s not just that Musharraf comes across like a clown in the world with no authority. The military has a job: defend the borders of Pakistan- not to involve itself with managing the country. He has taken the professionalism away from the Pakistan Army and engrossed the army in corruption. Transparency International (European Think Tank) rates the Musharraf government more corrupt than either BB government or Nawaz Sharif. My friend we are all Pakistan- forget about individual leaders- let’s talk about creating institutions and systems where we are all collectively building our beloved Pakistan. Let’s not look for leaders and heros to save us- we can save ourselves by starting to respect our laws and constitution. Let’s bring back any form of democracy before the ignorance of Musharraf causes more damage.
Although it’s unfair for military to involve in managing the countries politics but what have the politicians before Musharaf given to us EXCEPT corruption, poverty and freedom of practicing extremism in terms of religion. You are right we all have to build up future of this country but not with involving religion into Politics: by not imposing the sharia law. Arab influence and their sponsorship for making Pakistan little Saudi Arabia has to stop. And for controlling all this corruption, extremism and ignorance I think you can’t have somebody better than Musharaf. FULL STOP
I think General Pervaiz Musharaf was forced by the Militants to take extreme steps of use of force inside a mosque. We being muslims should be ashamed of the fact that our Religious Teachers who claim to be doing Jehad are using women and childrens as a sheild. Any one that can take a weapon inside a mosque or have bombs stored inside a mosque should not be considered a Shaheed / Martyr. This situation was created by Islamic Extremists and outside forces that do not want political stability in Pakistan. Sharia law is used as a cover to create instability in the country.
I just hope that we all can see this and agree that Islam does not teach all this. I hope that after this operation the Government and specially General Musharaf would clean up the Red Mosque area and do necessary repairs or rebuild the Mosque and hopefully place people in the mosque that actually preach Islam and not violence.
We as a country have suffered enough due to inside forces that work against our country. Its about time that we progress and show the world that we are not a third world country anymore.
Shah why not ask impartial agencies around the world how they grade the military in Pakistan- our corruption ranking under Musharraf is worse than either BB or Nawaz Sharif! As for our economic and health indices they are just as dismal. This despite all the aid we are getting for the so called war on terror. Nawaz or BB didn’t receive the loot that Musharraf is getting from the West. Ultimately we have to return to a democratic dispensation with strong institutions. If Musharraf has any respect for the military or Pakistan he should step down now and return the country to elected leaders- good or bad that is our destiny- not to be ruled by an illiterate incompetent like Musharraf!
Years of Musharraf rule has brought ridicule to Pakistan on the world stage; Do you not remember the Washingtom Post headlines when he was caught in his own lies. First claiming that women in Pakistan were purposely getting themselves raped to get immigration and then denying he would say such a stupid thing. The newspaper (Washington Post)simply released the recording of him saying the very words he denied saying. I am too much a Pakistani to let our nation remain as a military dictatorship/Banana Republic with someone like Musharraf at the helm.
Mahmood, no leader in the entire world history has been perfect and perhaps won’t be but you can see their work done with comparing them with each other and the progress they’ve made in their time. You can’t just be chief of army staff if you are illiterate. There are times when military powers are necessary to control the situation in country, otherwise Muhammad Ali Jinnah wouldn’t have asked for a new country on the basis of uncontrollable religious discrimination and extermism. Even though it was more about gaining leadership because a non-religious man drinking alcohol has got to have a purpose behind asking for a new country for Muslims ONLY. The problem with our country’s is that our candidates for presidency are corrupt so it’s unsafe to give away country in such hands by playing the election drama once again. It’s also unrealistic to think of Pakistan without Musharraf and freedom of religious extremism at the same time. Elected candidates just can’t control it this way.
Shah, Jinnah established and secured Pakistan through patently constitutional means- he was a lawyer and man of principle who envisioned Pakistan as a functioning democracy. (I’m not talking about his personal habits or lifestyle)If you look back there are several instances in which he explicity spoke of the military’s role as being subservient to the elected executive. As for extremsim and religious discrimination, I believe such social ills are fostered under the military set up. Read the New York Times analysis and the Washington Post analysis of the last two days. Both refer to increasing instability under the current dictatorship beacause a military ruler such as Musharraf has no moral authority to lead a consitutional democracy. We don’t need to control anyone in Pakistan- we need to educate our fellow citizens and develop institutions. Why are so many Pakistanis successful in other parts of the world when we find it so difficult to succeed at home- it’s not for lack of talent but because we have yet to respect institutions. Tell me honestly, if another army officer were to walk into the Presidential suite and kick out Musharraf we would all say it’s unlawful but who’s to stop it. People like Musharraf have done it so why shouldn’t anyone else. At some point we have to get on with the exercise of democracy. Incidentally I do think that Musharraf is a fucntional illiterate apart from being incompetent. Trust me we’ve had many Chiefs of Army staff who have been incompetent if you look back. Musharraf was made Chief by Nawaz Sharif superceding even more senior Generals becasue the latter thought him pliant- just like Bhutto did with Zia. I Hope that this time the dictator is charged in court to send a clear message to other usurpers of civil society not to interfere in government. So it goes but I pray for Pakistan and for the development of institutions.
How is it possible that the lal masjid students are armed, although the madrassa is in the capital under supervision of ISI? might this was the plan of isi.
AAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!
Just Tell Me Two Things
Did ever our Army wins a battle
1948, 1965, 1971, Sia Chin, Kargil ????????????
They Only can concure their own country and can Kill their fellow country men.
Second What is the defination of Shaheed
what i read is ” Who Dies for Allah and Islam is called Shaheed”
the soldiers killed in this mosque attack are they realy shaheed?
I think that the conversation is getting a bit of topic. Our Army may not have decisively win any war but we kept our much bigger neighbour at bay in 1948 and 1965. As for the limited skirmish at the Rann of Kutch most observers say we were winning but our own leaders slowed things down. I often wonder whether a better strategy would have improved the outcome of the 1965 war since things were intially going in our favour. I am from Sialkot district and my parents and grandparents always spoke proudly of the military and the sacrifices made especially at the battle of Chawinda. Although we lost the 1971 war our hands were tied due to the political incompetence of military leaders and the rebellion. Otherwise our military has remained a formidable deterrent agaisnt aggression by our more powerful neighbours. We should never dismiss the role of our military in safegaurding our sovereignty but it should have no role in running our country. Musharraf himself is responsible for tarnishing the image and professionalism of the Pakistani military. I know it’s hard to support the military when they try to restore law and order against groups such as the Lal Masjid. It’s not the fault of the rank and file soldiers or jawans that the Generals and Musharraf are corrupt and incompetent. Getting back to your original point maybe a dedicated SWAT team formed from police units would be better to deal with this type of challenge instead of the Pakistani Army.
I agree that lal masjid folks took law into own hands but they did highlight failure of law and order. Islamabad is full of brothels and alcohol is freely available. The authorities have been knocking down masjids to grab prime land which they will from lal masjid too since you probably heard precursor words that buildings occupied government land.
Remember kargil, unprovoked war , guess who was leading that , yes general saab. He has also given alcohol licenses to ministers in view of legalizing it since baba bush only visits countries which server him his favorite.
Comments from people are so alarming and based on media lies spread by government. Arms were given by government no doubt and the later display is joke , if they had rockets and other heavy arms, why didn’t they use them, were they saving them for life after death.
Another comment on talk failures, government say he was buying time, my question is time for what ?, he had no water no electric bad air running out of food ..He was buying more time for what?
Real answer was the day they were declared militants from students, not many of you noticed the change in wording but what it meant was they should be killed since its American term for license to kill.
All I can say is if government can do its job no lal masjid case would ever happen. By the way shame on government that they had to ask Edhi trust for ambulances, they are so corrupt that they don’t even have own resources to handle minor disasters of own creating.
For those of you praising military shame on you since military has always taken all of your resources for themselves, just go and look at their complexes. As for protection, well loosing half of the country and loosing most of Kashmir, I am sure we could have negotiated better deal with India without arms.
The whole case, I wont call it operation , came from CIA book, its been used in Iraq , Afghanistan etc. i.e. how to make negotiations fail so you can attack , remember Sadam and Taliban, they never did anything to Americans well may be didn’t give cheap drugs and cheap oil!!!
Thus proved…………. “Every thing is fair in love n power”
If person who “KIDNAPPED” three women can be treated like this, what about about a person who had “KIDNAPPED” 150 Million innocent people?
Most horrifing thing that is developing among the country men is the “INCREASING HATRED FOR PAK ARMY”………. just becoz of one person.
Please be pathetic to this beautiful country………let the democray florish, otherwise Americans prediction of ” NO PAKISTAN ON EARTH IN YEAR 2012″ may become true.
Ina lilla wa ina alehe rajiooon
Please pray for Shaheed Abul Rasheed Ghazi & all Shuhada of LAL Mosque fought for implementation of islam till shahadat,
Their way might be right or wrong, but their aim was to implement Islamic Laws in this country regardless of any personal benifits & anyone fought for islam to be implemented, weather they were in majority or minority & they prefer shahadat insted of stepping back, have an honour of Shaheed in this world & next.
(They do not want a Nishan-e-Haider, they have high values in front of Allah)
Allah know all right & wrongs.
Please recite 1-time Alhamdulillah rabul alameen complete & 3-time Quil howallah complete & pray for shudada of Islam.
Muslims are brothers. Make a brotherhood
Please forward after u pray for Shahada.
Dudes like inam need to live in Saudi Arabia NOT in Pakistan!
Dudes like Inam need to live in Saudi Arabia NOT in Pakistan!
I am not pleased whenever there is any loss of life in Pakistan; they are all our people from the soldier who is following orders to the brainwashed kids inside the madressas. We need to have proper schools and opportunities for our kids. Perhaps we should direct more of our resources to education and the strenghtening of insitutions but our leadership is corrupt from the top. Look at Musharraf’s Book tour- taking Pakistani state money to go on a trip to promote a book while you are sitting as a President. I agree that Musharraf is giving the Pakistani Army a bad name. The sooner he leabes the better but people like him need to be put on trial for treason agaisnt the state and consitution to send a clear message to the next fellow who wants to illegally seize power.
I pray that the souls of all the martyers of the Lal mosque are in peace, I ask that their families are blessed with peace and tranquilty.
The recent horrific assult on the Lal Mosque was a repeat of History-Many Karbala’s have been witnessed by the Muslims, over the enturies and this is a nother reminder
Water being cut off, electricity being cut, unbearable heat of the summer, surrounded by barbed wire and troops with high powered weapons helicopters tanks, who were they trying to defeat?
The Yazid’s orders for his troops were to kill them ALL. Does this statement sound familiar? As this story is of Karbala, those who were beloved, gave up their life for their Creator. From Him we came and to Him we will return. troops versus the poor thrreialt
Before we comment we shouls know the TRUTH.
Additional 800 requests for coffins from EDHI foundation? Why and for whom?
1) The Ghazi has agreed several minutes before the first bombing to a peaceful settlement (check with ministers and his mobile phone conversation) and asked all media be present to listen to this agreement
2)As his mother lay dying in his lap, he said to the ministers there is no turning back
3) Those who wanted to leave left, those who wanted to be SHAHEED stayed
4) No Water, Electricity etc for many of those inside
5) No help for the wounded Women and Children
6) Check out the Video footage of what occurred on each night after they bombed the Mosque-Yes Lightning, Fast wind and Heavey Rain
7)Government reports contrdicting their won statements-i.ethey had finger printed all those that had passed away, but admit that many bodies burnt so badly that they could not be identified!
9) Why did the Bushraffe order Bombing at night? Is this so you could not hear or see the screems of women and children? and their innocent blood running out of the Mosque?
i think this fight betveen muslims and so-cald muslim and i also thought muslims win
on 1st night of lal masjid student and abdul rashid gazi in grave skay cry (roya or chilaya) yani us ko bhi dukh hua.
is operation ki full enguiry honi chahy taky pta lagy k is operation man kitny log mary.
it is very imported. our jo log is operation ky responsibal hay un ko sza di jay
Ina lilla wa ina alehe rajiooon
Please pray for Shaheed Abul Rasheed Ghazi & all Shuhada of LAL Mosque fought for implementation of islam till shahadat,
Mr. Mahmood,
you gave the example of Chowindah you know when one of our general proudly told a Chines counterpart about that heroic effort of those Jawans the chines general asked where was your Anti Tank unit? our Fuji told sir it was in Nowshehra
Man stop praising them and point out thier faults they are not supper humans or only patriots….
Musharaf said in his speech there were 5000 students, we rescued 3300
where 1700 goes (they admit 73 were died there)
Others????? Army veporized them with thier Explosives or what?
They Hostage all pakistanis. Pakistan is made for these one million or two million peoples????
Who have no respect about Mosques and childrens and womens……
Mr. Mahmood,
you gave the example of Chowindah you know when one of our general proudly told a Chines counterpart about that heroic effort of those Jawans the chines general asked where was your Anti Tank unit? our Fuji told sir it was in Nowshehra
Man stop praising them and point out thier faults they are not supper humans or only patriots….
Musharaf said in his speech there were 5000 students, we rescued 3300
where 1700 goes (they admit 73 were died there)
Others????? Army veporized them with thier Explosives or what?
They Hostage all pakistanis. Pakistan is made for these one million or two million peoples????
Who have no respect about Mosques and childrens and women……
Guys you are all wrong, learn the basics of Islam before saying anything. What Lal Masjid did was Haram, read my opinion and then ask me questions ?
Here is the link, http://risingpakistan.wordpress.com/2007/07/14/learn-the-basics-of-islam-before-announcing-jihad/
from now onwards comment on this new link
Sher Kohh, I’m the first to acknowledge the faults of the Pakistani Military but I don’t blame the rank and file Jawans but the leadership. It is the leadership, especially Musharraf who has taken a proud insitution and sullied its reputation among the public. We can’t deny the efforts and sacrifices made by Jawans in the last wars and their steadfastness in dealing with an enemy larger in number and better equipped. You are probably right that poor logistics forced our Jawans to undertake heroic self sacrificing measures to stop Indian tanks at Chawinda. The point is the soldiers were prepared to lay down their lives for the nation and they did without hesitation. Our Generals and Musharraf have grown fat off corruption in their civilian roles but I still don’t blame the Jawan who is likely a hardy, upright dignified Pakistani villager who is doing his job. I’ve already said that any loss of life in Pakistan is deplorable, including the senseless loss of life at the Lal Masjid- they are our fellow citizens and each one of their lives is as valuable as ours. Musharraf used the poor students for his own political gains. He could have shut down the Masjid months ago or simply surrounded the area to slowly force the management to its senses. Musharraf can’t understand this becuse he too is illegally occupying the seat of the President. I believe Musharraf shouuld be charged with treason to send a message to people that you can’t disrepect the laws and consitution of Pakistan.
Brothers and sisters, 24 NaPak Army security personnel got killed and other 29 are wounded in Miranshah in a suicide attack this morning. These sort of attacks have become a routine since the “Operation Silence” had imposed on Lal Masjid. “Operation Silence” over the Innocent people has given birth to a much bigger “Operation Silence”, in which the Mujahideen will teach the NaPak Army, what does “Operation” mean? Insha-Allah, the day is not so far when Musharraf will be killed in an “Operation”. ALLAH(SWT) will take the best revenge of this brutality committed by the American dog Busharraf and his NaPak Army.
Why not work to remove Musharraf through peaceful means.
Those who are dying are all our brothers and sisters; both militants and the Army. By following the tactics of Musharraf- engaging in illegal operations and abusing the laws- we sink to the same level as Musharraf. Rallies and peaceul protests can do the job without harming our fellow citizens.
Why not work to remove Musharraf through peaceful means.
Those who are dying are all our brothers and sisters- our fellow citizens ; both militants and the Army personel. By following the tactics of Musharraf- engaging in illegal operations and abusing laws- we sink to the same level as Musharraf. Rallies and peaceul protests can do the job without harming our fellow citizens.
Come on guys i wrote a new article regarding terrorism of lal masjid and abdul aziz….please read it here and comment on it
http://risingpakistan.wordpress.com/2007/07/14/learn-the-basics-of-islam-before-announcing-jihad/
i can just say if this all were fair then it should be open for media to show the transparency . it was a brutal action by president. he tried to lead like hitler.
how can he say its islami jamhoriya pakistan ,if there is no right to protest by staunch believe muslims.
maulana and his fellows were teased against thier hard islamic views and remark for so long ,and make them ready and assure for this operation thats why they collected the gun for their defence , which is absolutely their right
all above they didnt misuse the women and kids ,otherwise they use them so suiside blast during operation to kill the army.
musharaf !!! what you will do when these innocent will ask the answer in qayamat in hashar ,
ik admi bhi bhoka soye tu uski zimaydari president ki hoti hay tum nay tu itnay baykasor mar daly ,for the sake of your satisfaction / ego and name .
Shame Musharraf!!!!!!
president of pakistan is responsible for this blood shed. he is trying to resolve the issues by power. this matter should have solved by dialouges.
the silence operation is live example of the failure of the government. they should have use the brains.
Pervez Musfraf is not Muslim. He is no religion. He is not army person. He is not human being he a wild blood animal, he can gives her mother to USA free of cost. What I can say about him. All Pakistani HATE him. Allah Cursh him as soon as possible I pray.
shame musharaf
musharaf has killed innocent people and removed their dead bodies too. he should be prepared now because now Allah tala must have planned something for him which would be very disastrous. inshallah.
Brothers and sisters, here is a “shair” that perfectly suits this American dog who is ruling our country through gun-point.
AMRIKYON NE KUTTA PALA
GENERAL MUSHARRAF WARDI WALA
I’m not aware of all the sayings on the streets of Pakistan against Musharraf but I’ve heard my share of anti Musharaf comments. For years I’ve heard folks call Musharraf Bey sharraf . More important than this verbal rhetoric would be political agitation and protests to bring down the dictatorship and return Pakistan to a fucntioning democracy as envisioned by her founders. Rule of law and respect for our counsitution should be the mantra. I have a lot of faith in the new generation of Pakistanis who are sick of corruption and incompetence. I just want progress and stability in my beloved Pakistan. Political leades won’t matter when we have insitutions and a framework. Leaders will come and go but the system will remain- as in the West. It’s 2007 and Pakistan can be so much more than what it is- we all know we are better than the Arabs, Iranians or Afghanis in terms of intelligence and work ethic. It’s insulting that even the little Indians next door are progressing when the martial races of Pakistan are falling behind- Why should a venture capitalist in Europe or America invest in a dictatorship. I’m tired of being run by ignorant and illiterate military men who make our nation of 160 million look like a Banana Republic. Let’s show the world we are a principled nation by not calling for anyone’s death- rather work for democracy through mass action. When rule of law and the consitution is restored, criminals like Musharraf should be brought to trial and charged with treeason after due process. This would send a message to the world and also to future corrupt military Generals that the fate of all who violate the consitution will be the same- shame and ignomy.
Why must everyone make this political? Yes it is mainly to be considered in a political concept, but look at it individually, the moulana Ghazi was so brain-washed, that his mother was dying in his lap, he still had a hard-heart.. you would think that at that moment, he will surrender. Toh aisa banda kisi aur bachay yah aurat ki parwah kyun aur kesay karega?? He just cares about his selfish reasons, which is that he wants to dictate the nation. He is DEMANDING control over the entire country, AND is blackmailing the nation with lives of children and women.
Bombing at night is due to not giving away your position to enemies, pagal logon, apni comment chornay say pehlay thora parh likh loh. Logon ki cheekhnay aur ronay ki away toh din ho ya raat, ayegi hee ayegi.
The Maulana was trying to exert control in an illegal manner- Musharraf continues to exercise control which he seized in an unconsitutional and illegal manner. What’s the difference?
This operation is dark lesson in the history of pakistan. We strickly protest this operataion as it may be solved by dialogues but unfortunately some dirty eggs do not like to solve this major issue by positive manner. We pray that ALLAH desroy these peoples as he destroy the peace of our country.
Let’s work peacefully to return Pakistan to a fucntionng democracy where there insitutions and rule of law. Let’s move to oust the illegal dictator who has seized control in an unconsitutional manner and who has made Pakistan an embarrassment to patriotic Pakistanis.
Dear Nadir
You are right it is a NaPak Army who only obey orders of
those non muslim type of generals to Destory and burn the Mosques and Madrasas with phosphoras bombs
and burn the Holy Quran and throw them in the gutter lines
“May Allah Destory them”
and Burn the helpless little girls mercilessly
They never obey the orders of Allah because they even dont know the orders of Almighty
Its not a Ilsamic army
for 50 Mujahideen They deploy 15000 miltary and non miltray Sherdil
Jawans
We all follow the tenets of Islam to our best understanding but it is not wise to let our emotions get the better of us. I am the first to say that the Lal Masjid affair was a fiasco brought about by a corrupt and illiterate Military General and his cabal of corrupt followers. However, it is unfair of accusing anyone in a Muslim nation, especially the common foot soldiers of our military of burning the holy Quran or throwing our holy book in the gutter. An act of such depravity simply isn’t possible. These type of comments do not serve any constructive purpose in the debate to return Pakistan to a civil society where there is rule of law and religious freedom as laid out in our constitution. My pint remains that a military dictator has no moral authority in the eyes of the people which is why everyone feels they are entitled to take the law into their own hands. If Musharraf can seize power illegally, ram road whatever he wants down the throats of Pakistanis and continue with a level of corruption greater than Nawaz or BB – surely no Pakistani will believe in rule of law. For this Musharraf must be tried for treason to send a message to all and sundry that our laws will be respected. Those who do not will pay a price.
Dear Mahmood
Please Tell me That i write some thing False…..
Didnt you see the burnd Qurans the Bodies and the soldiers Wearing Boots Standing in the Mosque and later found Burnt and Torn Quranic Pages in Gutter lines the bloody cloths burned pieces of bodies
Is that wise to follow an unislamic order ??????????????
If i order you to kill a person and you obey, on judgement day what you say to Allah ??? that i give you the order so you are innocent
He made you with brain and you are responsible of your doings you are not an animal that i force you to do that
On judgement day people say Satan force us to make sin and satan say i didnt they follow me ( both goes to Hell )
The Lal Masjid operation was necessary and justified after six months of patience and nine days of giving the armed fanatics inside chances to surrender. The deaths and the destruction that followed are the responsibility of the Lal Masjid Brigade, who even refused to listen to the Imam-e-Kaaba.
Musharraf made a mistake in suspending the CJ, he made the right decision to destroy the Lal Masjid Brigade.
Toataly wrong decision, attaking on Lal Masjid. Shame for us , in a muslim Country mulsim Ministers muslim army killing muslim even in Masjid , This one did Sadam Husain in past and now doing Musharraf for creating an atmosphere to invite other cuntries in pakistan proof (as we see and listen that america say we can attack any doubt spot in pakistan any time to finish terror). Now we have ( our government) proof that there are terrorsit in masjads and madrasas and people go in masjids to practice five time terror, sorry to say but so is the reality becaz what present governament did, lal masjid issue is an international issue becaz pakistani governament has attached this one with talliban and talliban are selfly created most wnated terrorist in the world. Musharraf did so to make happy Europ and America, to prevet his own illegel Government ( by showing himself Herro aainst terror in pakistan) to delay the allections…. In 1992 in india hidu attacked on Babri masjid and shahied it and we see how did protest all muslim in india, and now more worst is going in pakistan and we all are silent cllaping and happy saying Musharraf did good. No he did totaly wrong and distroy the image of pakistan.I ask from those who are saying that musharraf did good then answer me what did pakistan achive from lal majid oppration? in next i will told you what did pakistan loos in this opperation?
it was not in the favour of islam and muslims. the muslim army Killed the muslim students for what ? they were not demanding any thing unislamic are anything against Pakistan, becouse pakistan was made for muslims to live according the islamic ways of life. their way of demand may be incorrect but the funnishment was just too much.
What the fuck uses playing at have some respect its a place of worthship the house of allah or you have forgot that. what did raid on lal mosque achieve the dead of 20 innocent muslims. This all is the agenda of the west
What the fuck uses playing at, have some respect its a place of worthship the house of allah or you have forgot that. what did raid on the lal mosque achieve the death of 20 innocent muslims. This all is the agenda of the agenda of the west
May Allah be with you
We are all Muslims and we all respect places of worship, mosques or otherwise. It is a fundamental premise of our faith. Having said that, what does a civil society do when members of the mosque take the law into their own hands. If they feel so stronlgy about imposing Islamic laws in the land, why not work legally within the system to push for laws and action against acts which are felt to be unislamic. My main point of contention is that we need to build a civil society run by laws and our constitution. I know what most Western newspapers are saying. They believe strongly that Musharraf’s illegal occupation of the presidency and abrogation of laws creates lawlessness and insecurity. People see that Musharraf can do as his wish with no regard for the laws, so why should the Lal Masjid folks follow any laws?
I believe that all Pakistanis need to follow our laws and respect our consitution. We are not some Afghanistan- our people are not Arabs, Persians, Turks or Afghanis- we are Pakistanis and as such we should hold ourselves to higher accountability by establishing rule of law. In short both Musharraf and the Lal Masjid folks are law breakers- you decide who is the bigger law breaker- maybe Musharraf becasue he has set the whole thing in motion. By the way I still believe the Lal Masjid affair was initially orchestrated by Musharraf himself.
it is just as clear as crystal everyone has its own views but being a muslim………….is it rite to do all ds stuff with our religious places n the ppl who r here to tell us our norms as a muslim……its just a drama to kill the ppl who wanna make pak a fullfledge muslim state not a so called one…….n dats all..its totally an unfair game
jo log musharraf ko support karte hai wo log sacche musalman nahi hai apne aap ko pehchano musalmaano
Its a shame hw some Muslim ediots supports these terrorits……..terrorists r terrorists b it men or women !!
Rajiv Gandhi was assasinated by ladies………( terrorists L.T.T.E. )
Im a Hindu bt can say yes L.T.T.E. is a terrorist org.
bt for some Muslims its so hard 2 realize the fact………..these so called Muslims r a menace 2 the society………….wake up before they started killing u !!
3 cheers for Musharraf for fucking the asses of these bastards !!!!!!!
lets make this world a better place………………..this is not 7th century its 21st century!!! grow up guys………..
So Dear Mehmood,
What you say now
about the peacefull means to remove Mush
weraing
Good Content – [url=http://www.intersponse.net]website traffic[/url] Will recommend. Website Traffic Visit us as well
I HATE ALL THOSE PEOPLE WHO WERE INVOLVE IN THIS OPERATION.I WILL SEE THEM ON THE DAY OF JUDGEMENT.THIS OPERATION IS OCCURED ON BEHALF
OF AMERICA IS IT OUR FRIEND? IT COULD BE OUR FRIEND ANY TIME? NEVER NEVER .WHY DO U AGREE WITH PRESIDENT BUSH(STUPID).
Lal masjid people lost their lives but they keep up the pride of islam. They wanted only islam and our govt tried to insult them. Their insult was insult of islam. So they lost their lives but keep the pride of islam up.
Thanks a lot to Lal masjid.
This is totally wrong information they were having any negative agenda against common man or liberal people. They were having a massage of peace for all world but not for protitutes and cruel people
yeh sub kam musharaf gandu nay kia ha,,,,or masoom bacho ka qatal e aam kia ha…..manay khud lal masjid may 3 days guzaray thay..or mjhy nhi lgta k yeh sub asla un k pass pehlay say mojoud tha.. balkay yeh sab kuch media or america ko dikhanay k liay aik drama tha..or pakistani qoum ko bewaqoof banana tha…..
they just make a drama amrica he don’t like islam even muslims .i pray one day in pakistan every body hate amrica . me i prayu for all muslims